PubliusNYPublic records research

Freedom of Information Law · Town of East Greenbush

Records requested, and what came back

I filed ten FOIL requests with the Town between 16 July and 31 August 2026, broken down here to the 57 numbered items they contain. Every request on this page is one I submitted myself, and every status shown is drawn from the Town's own written replies to me. The request of 20 July was not itemised and contributes none of the 57, although it has had no response at all. I filed one administrative appeal on 21 August. Status as of 19 November 2026, drawn entirely from the Town's own replies.

Separately, seven questions were put to the Town Attorney on 4 September 2026. Six have had no answer. The seventh has had no answer from the Attorney either. It was closed by a records request of mine instead: the Town marked that request complete on 24 September without producing the document and without saying it does not exist.

Download report PDF Editable copy ODT

The PDF is the version to attach to an email. An emailed attachment becomes part of the recipient's own record; a link does not. It was prepared for the Town Board meeting of 18 November 2026 and its day counts are frozen at that date, so they read one lower than the live counts on this page.

4Items produced
9Partially produced
4Answered: no records
40No response of any kind
6 of 7Attorney questions unanswered
Produced Partially produced No responsive records No response

One pattern runs through all of it. The Town's reply form offers two boxes: Requested Record/s Attached and Unable to Locate Record/s. There is no option for a partial response. On 24 August and again on 23 September the first box was checked and the second left blank, closing requests in which numbered items had received no response either way. Both original July requests, and Request G, expressly asked for a written statement where a record does not exist. None has been provided.

The requests

Records of any ALPR devices currently installed or in trial Partially produced

Filed 16 Jul 2026Acknowledged 17 Jul 2026Open 126 daysClosed: Form marked “Requested Record/s Attached”, 24 Aug 2026

#Item requestedStatusWhat happened
1All records identifying any ALPR device installed or operating within the Town, including location, owner, operator, installation date, and the agency whose database receives its data.Partially producedCamera list with locations and current status produced 24 Aug. Install date, owner, operator and receiving agency not produced.
2All records regarding any device operating under a trial, demonstration, pilot, evaluation or pre-contract arrangement.ProducedAnswered in the 24 Aug production.
3All agreements, permits, licenses, right-of-way authorizations, pole attachment agreements or approvals relating to ALPR devices within the Town.No responsive recordsNothing responsive produced.
4All records regarding Department access to, searches of, or participation in any Flock database or sharing network, including user accounts and data-sharing agreements.No responsive recordsNothing responsive produced.

The request asked, under Public Officers Law § 89(3), for written certification where no records exist for a numbered item. That certification was renewed item by item on 25 August and has not been provided.

Flock contract, cost, procurement, grant funding, and ALPR policy records Partially produced

Filed 16 Jul 2026Acknowledged 17 Jul 2026Open 126 daysClosed: Form marked “Requested Record/s Attached”, 24 Aug 2026

#Item requestedStatusWhat happened
1Any contract, vendor agreement, purchase order, quote or proposal, including amendments, renewals, addenda and attached terms.Partially producedAgreements and amendments produced. The quote named in Resolution 148-2022 and any renewal documents were not. Invoice INV-71462 is marked “Renewal - 2024”, which indicates a renewal record exists.
2All records of total cost, payment schedule and funding sources, including budget line, appropriation, resolution, or state or federal grant.Partially producedOne invoice produced, for 2025. Other years, and the budget line for account code 31204.01 named in Resolution 148-2022, were not.
3All records of any grant application, award or correspondence about potential grant funding, including work by Lexipol or another consultant.No responsive recordsNothing responsive produced.
4All records of the procurement method used or planned, including competitive bidding, cooperative purchasing, or an exemption under General Municipal Law § 103.No responsive recordsNothing responsive produced.
5Any written policy, draft policy or procedure governing use, retention, sharing, audit or access controls.Partially producedDraft Policy 426 dated 8/11/2026 produced, marked DRAFT on every page and apparently ending mid-section at 426.7. No adopted policy, and nothing covering 2021 to date.
6All records of the number, type and proposed or planned locations of devices under any executed, pending or proposed agreement.Partially producedCurrently installed devices covered. Proposed or planned devices, including other camera types, were not.
7Any penalty, liability, indemnification or termination clause relating to unauthorized access, breach, misuse or early cancellation.ProducedAnswered in the 24 Aug production.
8Any Town Board resolution, minutes or authorization relating to approval, consideration or execution of any such agreement.Partially producedResolution 148-2022 produced. Minutes, any authorization for the trial period that resolution refers to, and any authorization for the agreement executed 28 Sept 2021 were not.

Same § 89(3) certification request, renewed 25 August, not provided.

Communications with Flock representatives, and vendor-provided goods, services or hospitality No response

Filed 20 Jul 2026Acknowledged 5 Aug 2026Open 122 days

The only response within five business days was an automatic out-of-office reply. Acknowledged twelve business days after filing. On 1 September the Clerk wrote: “I estimate that I will be able to gather this information by September 11th, 2026.” Nothing has been produced. That is 69 days past the Town's own estimate.

ANetwork and organization audit logs, since inception No response

Filed 27 Jul 2026Acknowledged 5 Aug 2026Open 114 days

#Item requestedStatusWhat happened
1Network audit. Every search run by an outside agency against Town cameras, with searching user and agency, date and time, stated reason or case reference, parameters, and scope.No response–
2Organization audit. Every search run by Town personnel or with Town credentials against any camera or network, same fields.No response–
3The complete field schema or data dictionary for audit and search logs, including fields absent from a standard export.No response–
4The retention period applicable to audit and search logs, and all logs retained.No response–
5Hot list matches, alerts and notifications, and any evidence exports, saved searches or case attachments.No response–

Plate numbers were expressly not requested and their redaction accepted in advance. Redaction of searching user, agency, date, reason, case number or scope was not accepted. On 1 September the Clerk wrote that an organizational audit could be produced “within 2 months of this email”, and explained that the audits are run by a single Sergeant, only in 30-day periods, depending on call volume. That estimate expired 1 November.

BDetection records, full retention period No response

Filed 27 Jul 2026Acknowledged 5 Aug 2026Open 114 days

#Item requestedStatusWhat happened
1All detection or capture records retained, with every associated field: plate, date and time, camera identifier and GPS, direction of travel, and derived vehicle characteristics, together with the images where retained.No response–
2If denied, the specific subsection of § 87(2) relied on, and whether the Town asserts § 87(2)(b) personal privacy and whose interest.No responseNot answered.

The request noted at the time that these records delete on a rolling basis and that the responsive set shrinks each day the request is pending. Under the thirty-day retention setting, the records sought would ordinarily have expired before the Town's response period ran. No record confirming deletion has been produced.

CALPR policy, sharing agreements, and system configuration Partially produced

Filed 27 Jul 2026Acknowledged 5 Aug 2026Open 114 days

#Item requestedStatusWhat happened
1Any policy, general order, SOP, directive or user agreement governing use of the system, including the internal policy described by the Chief on 15 July.Partially producedDraft Policy 426 produced 24 Aug, marked DRAFT throughout.
2Records of the monthly audit reviews described at the 15 July meeting: who conducted each, period covered, findings, corrective action.No response–
3Any records of misuse, policy violation, discipline or corrective action arising from use of the system.No response–
4Training materials or acknowledgment forms provided to or signed by users.No response–
5All records identifying agencies the Town shares data with, and the Town's requests to search other agencies' data, including the monthly sharing report the Chief referenced.No response–
6Any written sharing agreement, memorandum of understanding or reciprocal arrangement with another agency.No response–
7Records showing whether any federal agency has had access to Town ALPR data, and on what basis.No response–
8Current retention period for detection records and the complete history of changes, with dates and who authorized each.No response–
9Whether the system requires a search reason and case number at time of search, and the history of that setting. If either is optional rather than enforced, to so state.No response–
10Whether the Town enabled the filters described on 15 July preventing searches related to immigration or reproductive care, and the date enabled.No response–
11Whether the Town participates in the vendor's data use for product improvement under Section 4.1, and any election made.No response–
12The current agreement and all amendments, including the amendment reducing deployment from nine cameras to five, and any renewal or quotation under consideration.Partially producedThe executed agreement was provided 20 August by the Supervisor, outside the FOIL process.

DVendor materials provided to the Police Department No response

Filed 18 Aug 2026Acknowledged 20 Aug 2026Open 93 days

#Item requestedStatusWhat happened
1Sales presentations, slide decks, brochures, product literature, one-pagers and any other marketing or informational materials.No response–
2Written proposals, quotes, price sheets, order forms, statements of work and scoping documents.No response–
3Demonstration and pilot materials, including trial or demo agreements, loaner or evaluation equipment agreements, and any records describing a free trial, pilot or demonstration period.No response–
4Product documentation, user guides, administrator guides, training materials, release notes and feature descriptions.No response–
5Screenshots, screen recordings, video or webinar recordings provided to or viewed by Department personnel.No response–
6Correspondence between any Town officer or employee and any ALPR vendor representative, including all attachments.No response–
7Any non-disclosure, confidentiality or similar agreement executed with an ALPR vendor.No response–
8Any written question-and-answer document, FAQ, talking points or response-to-questions record supplied by a vendor to Town or Department personnel.No response–

Period 1 January 2019 to the date filled. The request specifically asked that this include records provided to the Police Department or the Chief but not presented to the Town Board. Acknowledged 20 August with the standard twenty-business-day notice. Nothing has been produced.

ETown Board records of prior ALPR presentations and approvals No response

Filed 18 Aug 2026Acknowledged 20 Aug 2026Open 93 days

#Item requestedStatusWhat happened
1Agendas, minutes and audio or video recordings of any Board meeting, workshop, work session or special meeting at which ALPR, Flock or any vendor was presented, demonstrated, discussed or voted upon.No response–
2Any record identifying attendance by a vendor representative at a Board meeting, workshop or work session, including sign-in sheets, agendas listing the presenter, and correspondence scheduling the appearance.No response–
3The text of any resolution, motion or authorization approving, amending or declining to approve the acquisition, installation, lease or use of ALPR cameras, with the recorded vote on each.No response–
4Any record reflecting an amendment to the number of cameras authorized, including any change from a larger to a smaller number.No response–
5Minutes of any executive session at which ALPR or Flock was discussed, and the motion stating the statutory basis for entering it under Public Officers Law § 105.No response–
6Any staff memorandum, department request, budget request, grant application or written recommendation to the Board concerning acquisition, renewal or expansion.No response–
7Any record reflecting Board review, approval or authorization of a renewal, extension or auto-renewal after the original approval.No response–
8Any procurement record generated under the Town's General Municipal Law § 104-b policy, including any determination that competitive bidding was not required.No response–

Period 1 January 2019 to 15 July 2026. Where a recording exists, the recording itself was requested, not only the written minutes. Acknowledged 20 August with the standard twenty-business-day notice. Nothing has been produced.

FHotlist topic selections and system policy settings No response

Filed 20 Aug 2026Acknowledged 21 Aug 2026Open 91 days

#Item requestedStatusWhat happened
1The list of NCIC hotlist topics currently selected by the Department, showing which are enabled and which disabled. A single screen in the Flock administrative interface.No response–
2The Department's Flock “Policies” settings page, showing configuration for audit assistance, federal agency sharing, and any restricted search categories.No response–

The request was expressly narrow, noted that each item is a single screen, asked for no search of files or correspondence, and asked that Item 1 be produced separately if Item 2 would take longer. Another New York department, Elmira, has produced the same record. Nothing produced.

GPurchasing and procurement records Partially produced

Filed 31 Aug 2026Acknowledged 1 Sep 2026Open 80 daysClosed: Form marked “Requested Record/s Attached”, signed by Purchasing 23 Sept, sent 24 Sept 2026

#Item requestedStatusWhat happened
1The Purchasing Policy and Procedures in effect during 2021 and 2022, meaning the policy Resolution 132-2023 amended and replaced.Partially producedClerk replied “I have asked for this policy - will send separately.” Resolution 132-2023 and May 2023 minutes were sent.
2Records of the annual review and Town Board approval of the purchasing policy required by General Municipal Law § 104-b, each year from 2019.No responseNo response given.
3Any sole source or single source determination for Flock, including the Board's written findings, the alternatives considered, the basis for finding the cost reasonable, the Sole Source Justification Form, and any vendor letter supporting it.No responseNo response given.
4Any Purchase Justification Form or documentation supporting use of another government's contract, state contract, OGS or GSA contract as the basis for the procurement.No responseNo response given.
5Any resolution, written designation or record authorizing a person other than the Supervisor to sign Flock contracts or amendments, specifically the amendment executed 16 December 2024.No responseNo response given. This is the record that bears on who holds title to the equipment.
6All purchase requisitions, purchase orders and vouchers relating to any payment to Flock from 1 January 2021.ProducedDocuments attached.
7All quotes obtained in connection with the procurement, and if fewer than the required number were obtained, the documentation stating why.No responseNo response given.
8All Town Board resolutions or Supervisor approvals authorizing renewal, extension or continuation of the agreement for each contract year from 17 May 2023.ProducedDocuments attached.

The request stated: “If a record identified above does not exist, please state that in writing rather than omitting the item.” Five of the eight items received no response of any kind. The reply form offers only two options, records attached or unable to locate. The first was checked; the second was not.

The appeal

Filed21 August 2026
CoveringThe six requests of 16, 20 and 27 July
ToDavid Gruenberg, Esq., Attorney to the Town and Records Access Appeals Officer
Submitted throughEllen Pangburn, Town Clerk and Records Access Officer
CopiedNYS Committee on Open Government
AuthorityPublic Officers Law § 89(4)(a); 21 NYCRR 1401.5(e)
Written determination due4 September 2026
Determination issuedNone
Overdue as of 19 Nov76 calendar days · 50 business days

The Committee on Open Government's Senior Attorney set out the consequence in writing on 20 August 2026: “The appeals officer must issue a written determination within ten business days of receipt. Failure to do so constitutes a constructive denial of the appeal and the requestor may seek judicial review by initiating an Article 78 proceeding in state supreme court.”

The appeal's fifth item of relief asked for confirmation of the name and address of the officer designated to determine appeals for the Town. The Clerk answered that on 27 August, confirming in writing that the appeal had been forwarded on 24 August to David Gruenberg, “attorney to the Town and also FOIL Appeals Officer”, and giving the mailing address shown on the Town's FOIL request form. No email address has ever been provided. A telephone number was given the following day, and every communication intended for the Attorney to the Town has been routed through the Clerk's office since.

Three days after the appeal was filed, the 24 August production substantially answered parts of both July 16 requests. On 25 August that was put on the record, with a request that the appeal be narrowed accordingly to the items that remained. That narrowing has never been acknowledged, because no determination has issued.

Questions to the Town Attorney

Seven questions were put to the Town Attorney on 4 September 2026, seventy-five days before the vote. Six remain unanswered. The seventh was not answered by the Attorney either. A records request of mine sought the same document, and the Town marked that request complete without producing it and without saying it does not exist.

At the 15 July 2026 meeting, at 01:10:00 in the Town's own recording, the Supervisor made the point himself: “there are questions that if you can’t answer, the answer is no.”

#QuestionStatus
Records retention
1 Whether the Town has assessed if the Flock retention configuration conforms to Resolution 214-2020 and LGS-1 Item 1241(b).
  • The Town's transparency portal, marked last updated 18 Nov 2026 and captured 19 Nov 2026, publishes the retention as thirty days. That is what the vendor publishes, not a Town record of the configured value, and no configuration record has been produced. Nothing states whether conformance with the Board's own 2020 resolution was ever assessed.
Unanswered
2 Whether the Town takes the position that ALPR data held on Flock's systems is a Town record for retention and disposition purposes under Public Officers Law § 86(4). Unanswered
Preservation
3 Whether the Town had any mechanism in July 2026 to preserve ALPR records on receipt of a records request, and whether one was used for the requests of 20 and 27 July. Unanswered
4 Whether the Town has assessed if it can comply with a records request for detection data, given the retention configuration and the statutory response period.
  • Unanswered as a question, answered in fact. The detection records requested on 27 July would ordinarily have expired before the Town's response time under FOIL had run. No record confirming deletion has been produced.
Unanswered
Audit and vendor access
5 Whether the agreement gives the Town a contractual right to a complete audit record of system activity, including activity by Flock personnel, and whether the Town has ever requested one.
  • The current online terms point the other way. Section 1.12 defines reports and analyses generated through the service as Flock Property with no export right, and Section 5 excepts from deletion any data Flock must retain for inter-agency audit log integrity.
Unanswered
6 Whether the Town can independently verify that the audit records available to it through the Flock console are complete. Unanswered
Contract execution
7 Whether the amendment executed 16 December 2024 by the Chief of Police was signed under any written designation of signing authority.
  • Answered by the records response rather than by counsel. The purchasing and procurement request was marked complete on 24 September with no designation produced. This bears on who holds title to the equipment, because the December 2024 amendment transferred hardware title to the Town.
Answered indirectly

The documents

Everything above is drawn from the file below. It is posted whole so that anyone can check this page against the underlying record rather than taking it on trust. If something here does not match what is in the archive, the archive governs, and I would like to be told.

Source documents, individually

The documents this page relies on, each on its own, for anyone who does not want the whole archive.

All three resolutions are also in the archive as .docx, as produced.

Complete archive

All 34 emails and all 20 produced documents, 187 pages in total, in the folder structure they arrived in. One download, 43 MB.

Status report

This page in long form: every request, every numbered item, and what happened to it. 19 pages.

Correspondence index

All 34 emails in date order with sender and subject, plus the full text of every message as JSON.

DateWhat was producedPages
20 Aug 2026Flock Safety service agreement and Department ALPR policy. Provided directly by the Supervisor, outside the FOIL process.
  • Responsive to the request of 16 July. The policy copy is marked DRAFT.
62
24 Aug 2026Scanned reply form covering both requests of 16 July.
  • Closed on the form's “records attached” box. Numbered items inside both requests had received no response of any kind.
56
15 Sep 2026Request G production: ten scanned invoices and order forms, three resolutions, and Town Board minutes.41
24 Sep 2026Scanned reply form marking Request G complete.
  • Five of its eight items had never been addressed, including the sole source determination, the purchase justification, the quotes obtained, and the signing authority designation.
13
21 Aug 2026The administrative appeal as filed, and the written response of the State Committee on Open Government dated 20 August.9
16 Nov 2026Written submission to the Clerk for this meeting: the agreement dates and governing terms, and the status of the attorney questions.5

That is 186 pages. The archive holds 187, because it also contains a one page record published by another New York department, filed with Request F as a comparator. It is not a Town production.

What was changed before posting

Three things, and nothing else was altered, reordered or removed. Mail routing headers were stripped, leaving sender, recipient, subject, date and body. Hidden document metadata was cleared. And two invoice pages were redacted.Set out in full in the archive's README

The redaction

The Flock invoices print the company's own bank account and routing numbers. Those two fields are blacked out on two pages and marked REDACTED BY PUBLIUS, so it is clear the redaction was made here and not by the Town. Invoice numbers, dates, terms and dollar amounts are untouched.Public record, lawfully obtained, withheld only because publishing it enables payment fraud

How the Town labels these

The Town modifies the subject line when it replies. Numbers appear that were not in the original request, among them 78, 79, 100, 101 and 102, sometimes alongside variations of my first name. Those are the Town's own, added for reasons it has not stated. They are not numbers I assigned, and they do not correspond to the request lettering used on this page. Replies also sometimes arrive on a different thread than the request they answer.Why the archive is ordered by date rather than by conversation

What was left alone

The Town's resolutions were produced as Word documents carrying the name of the employee who prepared them. That is official authorship of a public record, and removing it would weaken the authenticity of the production.Left as produced

Compiled from the Town's own correspondence: ten request emails, eleven acknowledgments and replies, two scanned reply forms, and the productions of 24 August, 15 September and 24 September 2026. Where a status reads no response, it means no response of any kind was given to that numbered item, not that a record was refused.