The transparency portal · Town of East Greenbush
The Police Department’s FLOCK page links to a transparency portal hosted by the vendor. It is live, it is linked here as the Town links it, and nothing on this page argues that it should not exist. What follows is what it publishes, where it answers questions the Town has left unanswered, where it contradicts itself, and the three things it cannot do no matter how accurate it is.
transparency.flocksafety.com/east-greenbush-ny-pd
Page marked “Last updated: Wed Nov 18 2026”. Captured 19 November 2026 at 9:28 AM. Figures below are as of that capture and may since have changed.
The PDF is a frozen record of the portal as captured on 19 November 2026. The portal itself can change without notice.
What it publishes
It also publishes a policy section: what is detected (license plates, vehicles) and not detected (facial recognition, people, gender, race), an acceptable use policy, a list of prohibited uses, an access policy, a hotlist policy, and a downloadable CSV headed Public Search Audit.
Traffic enforcement, which the portal lists as prohibited
Source one · the Town’s own linked transparency portal
The portal carries a downloadable Public Search Audit covering the previous thirty days. In the copy captured on 19 November 2026, covering 19 October to 17 November, two of the fifty-seven logged searches carry the offence type Traffic Infraction.
| Date and time (UTC) | Offence type | Networks | Record identifier, as published |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2026-10-30 22:03:32 | Traffic Infraction | 1 | 097df654-9f0c-46e0-8dbc-f2d742bc5e9f |
| 2026-10-30 23:03:35 | Traffic Infraction | 1 | b11f57a8-c3ef-4df6-b152-13a4712a2448 |
No outside data is involved in this one. The prohibition and the two searches are published by the vendor, on one page, linked from the Town’s own police page, and captured at the same moment. A third search in the same file is logged as “Hit and Run/Car Accident”, which may fairly be a criminal investigation rather than enforcement, and is set aside.
The Public Search Audit as downloaded from the portal on 19 November 2026 at 9:28 AM, unaltered. 57 rows covering 19 October to 17 November 2026, with the columns the portal publishes: record id, masked user id, search date, network count and offence type. The two Traffic Infraction rows quoted above are in it. Note what is not in it: no reason field and no case number field.
The portal publishes a rolling thirty days, so this file is the only record of that window once it scrolls off. It is republished here exactly as downloaded so that anyone can check the two rows above against the source rather than taking this page's word for it.
Source two · audit files released by other police departments
The second source is not the portal. It is the body of network audit files that other agencies across the country have released under their own public records laws, in which searches run with East Greenbush credentials appear. Those records cover a far longer period than thirty days, and they carry the free-text reason the searching officer typed, which the portal does not publish.
The reasons are the searching officer’s own words. Among them: “Traffic Infraction - speed”, run against 6,372 camera networks. “Traffic Infraction - RECKLESS DRIVER”. “Traffic Infraction - TEMP TAG”. And sixty-two entries reading simply “VTL”, the widest of which reached 6,410 networks.
A further 44 searches give “Hit and Run/Car Accident” as the reason. They are excluded from the figures above, for the same reason the portal’s one is excluded.
Where it answers what the Town has not
Four things published on that portal correspond directly to records I asked the Town for in writing, and have not received.
The two sharing lists
The portal states that sharing is opt-in and governed by defined agreements. No such agreement has been produced to me. Request C item 6 asked for any written sharing agreement, memorandum of understanding or reciprocal arrangement with another agency, and has had no response.
Why five cameras is a floor and not a total
The portal reports five total cameras and five plate readers. Taken at face value, that is a count of the devices in the Town’s own Flock account. It is not a count of the plate readers operating within the Town.
My request of 16 July defined an ALPR device as any plate reader or AI-assisted vehicle surveillance camera from any vendor, and defined within the Town as anywhere inside the corporate boundaries regardless of who owns the land, pole or structure it is mounted on, and regardless of whether the Town, another government agency or a private party owns or operates it. Item 3 asked for the agreements, permits, licences, right-of-way authorisations and pole attachment agreements that would identify them. The Town produced no responsive records.
The Town’s own paperwork carries a second figure as well: the agreement was amended to reduce deployment from nine cameras to five. The record of that amendment was requested as item 12 of Request C, which was answered only in part: the executed agreement was provided on 20 August by the Supervisor, outside the FOIL process. The written designation authorising who could sign it is item 5 of Request G, which has had no response.
One Town record does name locations. Resolution 40-2025 grants permission, subject to New York State Department of Transportation approval, to install plate reader equipment in State right of way at five places: eastbound Turnpike at the Sewer Treatment Plant, northbound Genet School and Route 4, Route 4 at Hewitt’s, southbound Troy Road at Grandview Drive, and westbound 3rd Avenue Extension at Krey Boulevard. The same resolution names the funding: the 2023 Governor of New York Grant for New Technology and Equipment to Prevent and Solve Crimes and Improve Public Safety.
That resolution describes equipment the Town asked to place in State right of way. It does not establish what else may be mounted within the Town by anyone else, which is what item 3 asked for and did not get. Read Resolution 40-2025.
So the honest statement is a floor. At least five. No record produced to date establishes a total.
Three things it cannot do
One. It is not the Town’s page. The address is on flocksafety.com, not eastgreenbush.org. It is published, hosted and controlled by the vendor. It can be changed, moved or withdrawn without notice to the Town or to the public, and a page on a vendor’s server is not a Town record held in the Town’s custody. It would not render to a plain fetch when I tried it, so the Town cannot archive or verify it with ordinary tools either.
Two. How its figures are produced is not established. Nothing produced to me shows whether they are generated automatically from the system, compiled by hand, or assembled some other way; who reviews them before publication; how often they update; what period each covers; or whether anyone at the Town has ever checked them against the system itself. That question has never been put to the Town. It should be.
Three, and this is the one that matters. Even taking every figure as accurate, a published summary is not the underlying record and cannot stand in for one. A count of searches is not the search log. A statement about retention is not the retention setting. A list of agencies is not the sharing agreements. A page showing what the system reports does not establish what the system holds, and it cannot show what is absent from it.
One open question, stated as a question
What should be asked
One request would resolve most of this page. Records establishing how the figures on the Town’s linked transparency portal are generated: from what source, by what process, how often they refresh, whether any Town officer reviews them before publication, and whether the Town has ever compared them against the system itself.
That question has never been put. The answer is either a process document, which would tell a resident a great deal, or nothing at all, which would tell them more.
On the question of fault. Nothing on this page asserts that the Town or the vendor has published anything knowing it to be wrong. A transparency page is better than no transparency page, and East Greenbush links to one. The point is narrower and it is about where a resident can and cannot get an answer. A page the Town does not host, cannot audit, and has not been asked to explain is not the same thing as the Town answering a question in its own words, on its own record, over its own signature.