[
 {
  "path": "FOIL and Emails/FOIL/FOIL Replies - Eric w PubliusNY - 78 and 79 ALPR Cost-Funding/RE_ PubliusNY-Eric - FOIL Request - Records of Any ALPR Devices Currently Installed or in Trial Within the Town of East Greenbush.eml",
  "date": "Fri, 17 Jul 2026 20:30:22 +0000",
  "iso": "2026-07-17T20:30:22+00:00",
  "from": "Ellen Pangburn <epangburn@eastgreenbush.org>",
  "to": "Eric <publiusnewyork@gmail.com>",
  "cc": "",
  "subj": "RE: PubliusNY-Eric - FOIL Request - Records of Any ALPR Devices  Currently Installed or in Trial Within the Town of East Greenbush",
  "body": "Good afternoon, Eric,\n\nI acknowledge receipt of your FOIL Request and have forwarded it to our Police Department. I will let you know when I receive a reply within 20 business days or let you know the status.\n\nKind regards,\n\nEllen\n\nEllen Pangburn, RMC\n\nEast Greenbush Town Clerk\n\nRegistrar of Vital Statistics\n\nFOIL Officer / Notary Public\n\nepangburn@eastgreenbush.org<mailto:epangburn@eastgreenbush.org>\n\nPhone:  518.477.7145 / Fax:  518.477.4508\n\n225 Columbia Tpk., Rensselaer, NY 12144\n\nTown Clerk\u2019s Office hours: 8:30-4:30\n\nFrom: Eric <publiusnewyork@gmail.com>\nSent: Thursday, July 16, 2026 8:14 AM\nTo: Ellen Pangburn <epangburn@eastgreenbush.org>\nSubject: FOIL Request - Records of Any ALPR Devices Currently Installed or in Trial Within the Town of East Greenbush\n\nDear Ms. Pangburn\n\nPursuant to the New York Freedom of Information Law (Public Officers Law, Article 6), I request copies of the following records held by the Town of East Greenbush, including its Police Department and all other town departments, boards, and offices.\n\nFor purposes of this request, \"ALPR device\" means any automated license plate reader, license plate recognition camera, or AI-assisted vehicle surveillance camera manufactured, sold, leased, or operated by Flock Safety or any other vendor. \"Within the Town\" means anywhere within the corporate/geographic boundaries of the Town of East Greenbush as defined by law, including all hamlets and neighborhoods (including but not limited to Clinton Heights, Hampton Manor, and Couse), regardless of who owns the land, pole, or structure on which a device is mounted, and regardless of whether the device is owned or operated by the Town, another government agency, or a private party.\n\nRecords requested:\n\n1.      All records identifying any ALPR device currently installed, mounted, or operating within the Town, including location, owner, operator, installation date, and the agency or entity whose database receives its data.\n2.      All records regarding any ALPR device within the Town operating under a trial, demonstration, pilot, evaluation, \"no-cost,\" or pre-contract arrangement of any kind, whether or not a formal contract exists.\n3.      All agreements, permits, licenses, right-of-way authorizations, pole attachment agreements, or approvals of any kind issued by or known to the Town relating to ALPR devices within the Town.\n4.      All records regarding East Greenbush Police Department access to, searches of, or participation in any Flock Safety database or data-sharing network, whether or not the Town owns or operates any ALPR devices \u2014 including any user accounts or login credentials issued to Town personnel and any memoranda of understanding or data-sharing agreements with other agencies.\n\nIf no records exist that are responsive to any numbered item above, I request, pursuant to Public Officers Law \u00a7 89(3), a written certification that the Town does not possess such records for that item.\n\nI request all records in electronic format (PDF or similar) to avoid copying charges. Per Public Officers Law \u00a7 89(3), I understand the Town has five business days to acknowledge this request and provide a determination on when the records will be made available. Please contact me by email with any questions.\n\nThank you,\n\nEric"
 },
 {
  "path": "FOIL and Emails/FOIL/FOIL Request - Records of Any ALPR Devices Currently Installed or in Trial Within the Town of East Greenbush/PubliusNY-Eric - FOIL Request - Records of Any ALPR Devices Currently Installed or in Trial Within the Town of East Greenbush.eml",
  "date": "Fri, 17 Jul 2026 20:30:24 +0000",
  "iso": "2026-07-17T20:30:24+00:00",
  "from": "Ellen Pangburn <epangburn@eastgreenbush.org>",
  "to": "Eric <publiusnewyork@gmail.com>",
  "cc": "",
  "subj": "RE: PubliusNY-Eric - FOIL Request - Records of Any ALPR Devices  Currently Installed or in Trial Within the Town of East Greenbush",
  "body": "Good afternoon, Eric,\n\nI acknowledge receipt of your FOIL Request and have forwarded it to our Police Department. I will let you know when I receive a reply within 20 business days or let you know the status.\n\nKind regards,\n\nEllen\n\nEllen Pangburn, RMC\nEast Greenbush Town Clerk\nRegistrar of Vital Statistics\nFOIL Officer / Notary Public\nepangburn@eastgreenbush.org<mailto:epangburn@eastgreenbush.org>\nPhone:  518.477.7145 / Fax:  518.477.4508\n225 Columbia Tpk., Rensselaer, NY 12144\nTown Clerk\u2019s Office hours: 8:30-4:30\n[cid:image001.jpg@01DD1609.909FA040]\n\nFrom: Eric <publiusnewyork@gmail.com>\nSent: Thursday, July 16, 2026 8:14 AM\nTo: Ellen Pangburn <epangburn@eastgreenbush.org>\nSubject: FOIL Request - Records of Any ALPR Devices Currently Installed or in Trial Within the Town of East Greenbush\n\nDear Ms. Pangburn\n\nPursuant to the New York Freedom of Information Law (Public Officers Law, Article 6), I request copies of the following records held by the Town of East Greenbush, including its Police Department and all other town departments, boards, and offices.\n\nFor purposes of this request, \"ALPR device\" means any automated license plate reader, license plate recognition camera, or AI-assisted vehicle surveillance camera manufactured, sold, leased, or operated by Flock Safety or any other vendor. \"Within the Town\" means anywhere within the corporate/geographic boundaries of the Town of East Greenbush as defined by law, including all hamlets and neighborhoods (including but not limited to Clinton Heights, Hampton Manor, and Couse), regardless of who owns the land, pole, or structure on which a device is mounted, and regardless of whether the device is owned or operated by the Town, another government agency, or a private party.\n\nRecords requested:\n\n  1.  All records identifying any ALPR device currently installed, mounted, or operating within the Town, including location, owner, operator, installation date, and the agency or entity whose database receives its data.\n  2.  All records regarding any ALPR device within the Town operating under a trial, demonstration, pilot, evaluation, \"no-cost,\" or pre-contract arrangement of any kind, whether or not a formal contract exists.\n  3.  All agreements, permits, licenses, right-of-way authorizations, pole attachment agreements, or approvals of any kind issued by or known to the Town relating to ALPR devices within the Town.\n  4.  All records regarding East Greenbush Police Department access to, searches of, or participation in any Flock Safety database or data-sharing network, whether or not the Town owns or operates any ALPR devices \u2014 including any user accounts or login credentials issued to Town personnel and any memoranda of understanding or data-sharing agreements with other agencies.\nIf no records exist that are responsive to any numbered item above, I request, pursuant to Public Officers Law \u00a7 89(3), a written certification that the Town does not possess such records for that item.\n\nI request all records in electronic format (PDF or similar) to avoid copying charges. Per Public Officers Law \u00a7 89(3), I understand the Town has five business days to acknowledge this request and provide a determination on when the records will be made available. Please contact me by email with any questions.\nThank you,\nEric"
 },
 {
  "path": "FOIL and Emails/FOIL/FOIL Replies - Eric w PubliusNY - 78 and 79 ALPR Cost-Funding/RE_ PubliusNY-Eric - FOIL Request -Flock Safety Contract, Cost, Procurement, Grant Funding, and ALPR Policy Records(1).eml",
  "date": "Fri, 17 Jul 2026 20:30:48 +0000",
  "iso": "2026-07-17T20:30:48+00:00",
  "from": "Ellen Pangburn <epangburn@eastgreenbush.org>",
  "to": "Eric <publiusnewyork@gmail.com>",
  "cc": "",
  "subj": "RE: PubliusNY-Eric - FOIL Request -Flock Safety Contract, Cost,  Procurement, Grant Funding, and ALPR Policy Records",
  "body": "Good afternoon, Eric,\n\nI acknowledge receipt of your FOIL Request and have forwarded it to our Police Department. I will let you know when I receive a reply within 20 business days or let you know the status.\n\nKind regards,\n\nEllen\n\nEllen Pangburn, RMC\n\nEast Greenbush Town Clerk\n\nRegistrar of Vital Statistics\n\nFOIL Officer / Notary Public\n\nepangburn@eastgreenbush.org<mailto:epangburn@eastgreenbush.org>\n\nPhone:  518.477.7145 / Fax:  518.477.4508\n\n225 Columbia Tpk., Rensselaer, NY 12144\n\nTown Clerk\u2019s Office hours: 8:30-4:30\n\nFrom: Eric <publiusnewyork@gmail.com>\nSent: Thursday, July 16, 2026 8:46 AM\nTo: Ellen Pangburn <epangburn@eastgreenbush.org>\nSubject: FOIL Request -Flock Safety Contract, Cost, Procurement, Grant Funding, and ALPR Policy Records\n\nDear Ms. Pangburn,\n\nPursuant to the New York Freedom of Information Law (Public Officers Law, Article 6), I request copies of the following records held by the Town of East Greenbush, including its Police Department and all other town departments, boards, and offices.\n\nRecords requested:\n\n1.      Any contract, vendor agreement, purchase order, quote, or proposal between the Town of East Greenbush (and/or the East Greenbush Police Department) and Flock Safety or any reseller of Flock Safety products, whether executed, pending, or proposed, including any amendments, renewals, addenda, or attached terms of service.\n2.      All records of the total cost, payment schedule, and funding source(s) for any such agreement, including any budget line item, appropriation, resolution, or state or federal grant.\n3.      All records of any grant application, grant award, or correspondence concerning potential grant funding for ALPR devices, license plate readers, or related surveillance technology, including any records of grant research, planning, or writing performed by Lexipol or any other consultant on the Town's behalf.\n4.      All records of the procurement method used or planned for any such agreement, including any competitive bidding records, cooperative purchasing agreement, or documentation of an exemption under General Municipal Law \u00a7 103.\n5.      Any written policy, draft policy, or procedure governing the use, data retention, data sharing, audit procedures, or access controls for any automated license plate reader (ALPR) system operated by or proposed for the Town.\n6.      All records of the number, type, and proposed or planned locations of ALPR devices to be installed in the Town under any executed, pending, or proposed agreement (e.g., Falcon/LPR cameras vs. Condor or other AI tracking cameras).\n7.      Any records of a penalty, liability, indemnification, or termination clause related to unauthorized access, data breach, misuse, or early cancellation within any such agreement.\n8.      Any Town Board resolution, meeting minutes, or authorization relating to the approval, consideration, or execution of any such agreement.\n\nIf no records exist that are responsive to any numbered item above, I request, pursuant to Public Officers Law \u00a7 89(3), a written certification that the Town does not possess such records for that item.\n\nI request all records in electronic format (PDF or similar) to avoid copying charges. Per Public Officers Law \u00a7 89(3), I understand the Town has five business days to acknowledge this request and provide a determination on when the records will be made available. Please contact me by email with any questions.\n\nThank you,\n\nEric"
 },
 {
  "path": "FOIL and Emails/FOIL/FOIL Request -Flock Safety Contract, Cost, Procurement, Grant Funding, and ALPR Policy Records/PubliusNY-Eric - FOIL Request -Flock Safety Contract, Cost, Procurement, Grant Funding, and ALPR Policy Records.eml",
  "date": "Fri, 17 Jul 2026 20:30:48 +0000",
  "iso": "2026-07-17T20:30:48+00:00",
  "from": "Ellen Pangburn <epangburn@eastgreenbush.org>",
  "to": "Eric <publiusnewyork@gmail.com>",
  "cc": "",
  "subj": "RE: PubliusNY-Eric - FOIL Request -Flock Safety Contract, Cost,  Procurement, Grant Funding, and ALPR Policy Records",
  "body": "Good afternoon, Eric,\n\nI acknowledge receipt of your FOIL Request and have forwarded it to our Police Department. I will let you know when I receive a reply within 20 business days or let you know the status.\n\nKind regards,\n\nEllen\n\nEllen Pangburn, RMC\nEast Greenbush Town Clerk\nRegistrar of Vital Statistics\nFOIL Officer / Notary Public\nepangburn@eastgreenbush.org<mailto:epangburn@eastgreenbush.org>\nPhone:  518.477.7145 / Fax:  518.477.4508\n225 Columbia Tpk., Rensselaer, NY 12144\nTown Clerk\u2019s Office hours: 8:30-4:30\n[cid:image001.jpg@01DD1609.9F3AA3C0]\n\nFrom: Eric <publiusnewyork@gmail.com>\nSent: Thursday, July 16, 2026 8:46 AM\nTo: Ellen Pangburn <epangburn@eastgreenbush.org>\nSubject: FOIL Request -Flock Safety Contract, Cost, Procurement, Grant Funding, and ALPR Policy Records\n\nDear Ms. Pangburn,\n\nPursuant to the New York Freedom of Information Law (Public Officers Law, Article 6), I request copies of the following records held by the Town of East Greenbush, including its Police Department and all other town departments, boards, and offices.\n\nRecords requested:\n\n  1.  Any contract, vendor agreement, purchase order, quote, or proposal between the Town of East Greenbush (and/or the East Greenbush Police Department) and Flock Safety or any reseller of Flock Safety products, whether executed, pending, or proposed, including any amendments, renewals, addenda, or attached terms of service.\n  2.  All records of the total cost, payment schedule, and funding source(s) for any such agreement, including any budget line item, appropriation, resolution, or state or federal grant.\n  3.  All records of any grant application, grant award, or correspondence concerning potential grant funding for ALPR devices, license plate readers, or related surveillance technology, including any records of grant research, planning, or writing performed by Lexipol or any other consultant on the Town's behalf.\n  4.  All records of the procurement method used or planned for any such agreement, including any competitive bidding records, cooperative purchasing agreement, or documentation of an exemption under General Municipal Law \u00a7 103.\n  5.  Any written policy, draft policy, or procedure governing the use, data retention, data sharing, audit procedures, or access controls for any automated license plate reader (ALPR) system operated by or proposed for the Town.\n  6.  All records of the number, type, and proposed or planned locations of ALPR devices to be installed in the Town under any executed, pending, or proposed agreement (e.g., Falcon/LPR cameras vs. Condor or other AI tracking cameras).\n  7.  Any records of a penalty, liability, indemnification, or termination clause related to unauthorized access, data breach, misuse, or early cancellation within any such agreement.\n  8.  Any Town Board resolution, meeting minutes, or authorization relating to the approval, consideration, or execution of any such agreement.\nIf no records exist that are responsive to any numbered item above, I request, pursuant to Public Officers Law \u00a7 89(3), a written certification that the Town does not possess such records for that item.\n\nI request all records in electronic format (PDF or similar) to avoid copying charges. Per Public Officers Law \u00a7 89(3), I understand the Town has five business days to acknowledge this request and provide a determination on when the records will be made available. Please contact me by email with any questions.\nThank you,\nEric"
 },
 {
  "path": "FOIL and Emails/FOIL/FOIL Request - Communications with Flock Safety Representatives and Related Vendor-Provided Goods, Services, or Hospitality/FOIL Request - Communications with Flock Safety Representatives and Related Vendor-Provided Goods, Services, or Hospitality.eml",
  "date": "Mon, 20 Jul 2026 15:07:34 -0400",
  "iso": "2026-07-20T15:07:34-04:00",
  "from": "Eric <publiusnewyork@gmail.com>",
  "to": "epangburn@eastgreenbush.org",
  "cc": "",
  "subj": "FOIL Request - Communications with Flock Safety Representatives and  Related Vendor-Provided Goods, Services, or Hospitality",
  "body": "Dear Ms. Pangburn,\n\nPursuant to the New York Freedom of Information Law (Public Officers Law,\nArticle 6), I request copies of the following records held by the Town of\nEast Greenbush, including its Police Department and all other town\ndepartments, boards, and offices.\n\nRecords requested:\n\n1. All communications (including email, letters, and text messages on Town\naccounts or devices) concerning ALPR devices, automated license plate\nreaders, license plate recognition cameras, or Flock Safety, between any\nTown officer or employee and Flock Safety, its representatives, or\nresellers - including but not limited to Joe DiStefano and Karl Bach - from\nJanuary 1, 2021 to the date of this request. This includes but is not\nlimited to communications of the Town Supervisor, members of the Town\nBoard, the Chief of Police, the Assistant Chief of Police, and the\nPurchasing Agent.\n\n2. All internal Town communications concerning ALPR devices or Flock Safety\namong or between the custodians named in item 1, from January 1, 2021 to\nthe date of this request.\n\n3. All records of any goods, services, trial or demonstration equipment,\ntravel, lodging, meals, event or conference registrations, tickets, or\nhospitality of any kind - including any equipment, software, or services\nprovided at reduced cost or at no cost during any trial, demonstration, or\npilot period - provided by Flock Safety or its representatives or resellers\nto any Town officer or employee, from January 1, 2021 to the date of this\nrequest.\n\n4. All records of any presentation, demonstration, or briefing given by\nFlock Safety or its representatives to any Town officer, employee, board,\nor committee, including any slide decks, handouts, marketing materials, or\nclaimed statistics provided to the Town, and any records of scheduling or\nplanning for such presentations, from January 1, 2021 to the date of this\nrequest.\n\n5. All records relating to the authorization, approval, or acceptance of\nany trial or pilot period of Flock Safety equipment or services by the Town\nor its Police Department, including the start and end dates of any such\ntrial and any records reflecting the value of equipment or services\nprovided during that period.\n\nIf no records exist that are responsive to any numbered item above, I\nrequest, pursuant to Public Officers Law \u00a7 89(3), a written certification\nthat the Town does not possess such records for that item.\n\nI request all records in electronic format (PDF or similar) to avoid\ncopying charges. If any portion of this request is denied or any record is\nwithheld or redacted, please cite the specific statutory exemption relied\nupon for each withheld or redacted record. Per Public Officers Law \u00a7 89(3),\nI understand the Town has five business days to acknowledge this request\nand provide a determination on when the records will be made available.\nPlease contact me by email with any questions.\n\nThank you,\n\nEric"
 },
 {
  "path": "FOIL and Emails/FOIL/FOIL Request - Communications with Flock Safety Representatives and Related Vendor-Provided Goods, Services, or Hospitality/Automatic reply_ FOIL Request - Communications with Flock Safety Representatives and Related Vendor-Provided Goods, Services, or Hospitality.eml",
  "date": "Mon, 20 Jul 2026 19:07:56 +0000",
  "iso": "2026-07-20T19:07:56+00:00",
  "from": "Ellen Pangburn <epangburn@eastgreenbush.org>",
  "to": "Eric <publiusnewyork@gmail.com>",
  "cc": "",
  "subj": "Automatic reply: FOIL Request - Communications with Flock Safety  Representatives and Related Vendor-Provided Goods, Services, or Hospitality",
  "body": "Thank you for your email. I will be out of the office the week of July 20th-24th for vacation. I will reply to your email when I return the week of July 27th.\n\nIf you're needing assistance today, please call the Town Clerk's Office at 518.477.7145 and Johnna (Deputy Clerk) or Ellen Schwab, Clerk, will be happy to help you.\n\nKind regards,\n\nEllen Pangburn\nEast Greenbush Town Clerk"
 },
 {
  "path": "FOIL and Emails/FOIL/FOIL Request A (2026-07-27) - Flock Network and Organization Audit Logs, Since Inception/FOIL Request A (2026-07-27) - Flock Network and Organization Audit Logs, Since Inception.eml",
  "date": "Mon, 27 Jul 2026 17:31:10 -0400",
  "iso": "2026-07-27T17:31:10-04:00",
  "from": "Eric <publiusnewyork@gmail.com>",
  "to": "epangburn@eastgreenbush.org",
  "cc": "",
  "subj": "FOIL Request A (2026-07-27) - Flock Network and Organization Audit  Logs, Since Inception",
  "body": "Ellen Pangburn\nTown Clerk / Records Access Officer\nTown of East Greenbush\n225 Columbia Turnpike\nRensselaer, NY 12144\n\nDear Ms. Pangburn,\n\nPursuant to the New York Freedom of Information Law, Public Officers Law\nArticle 6, I request the following records concerning the automated license\nplate reader (ALPR) system operated by or on behalf of the Town of East\nGreenbush, including any system provided by Flock Safety or a successor\nvendor.\n\nThis is one of three related requests I am submitting today. I have\nseparated them so that a delay or dispute over one does not hold up the\nothers. This request seeks system-generated log data only. A companion\nrequest (Request C) seeks written policies and governance records, and may\nbe more efficiently handled by the Police Department; please route it\naccordingly if that is appropriate.\n\nThis request covers the period from first use of any such system to the\npresent. I understand from the July 15, 2026 Town Board meeting that\ncameras have been in operation for approximately four years; please treat\n\"since inception\" as controlling rather than any specific year, so that a\ndate assumption on my part does not narrow the response.\n\nRECORDS REQUESTED\n\n1. NETWORK AUDIT - all records of searches or queries run by any outside\nagency, department, or entity against cameras owned, operated, leased, or\ncontributed by the Town of East Greenbush. For each record, please include:\nthe searching user and agency, date and time, the stated reason or case\nreference, the search parameters, and the scope of the search (number of\ncameras and networks reached, and the lookback period).\n\n2. ORGANIZATION AUDIT - all records of searches or queries run by Town of\nEast Greenbush personnel, or by anyone using Town credentials, against any\ncamera or network, whether the cameras searched were located in East\nGreenbush or elsewhere. Please include the same fields listed in item 1.\n\n3. The complete field schema or data dictionary for the system's audit and\nsearch logs - a list of every field captured in an audit or search record,\nwhether or not those fields appear in a standard export.\n\n4. The retention period applicable to audit and search logs, and all such\nlogs for the entire period retained. I note that at the July 15 Town Board\nmeeting the vendor's representative stated that audit logs are never\ndeleted, are owned by the Town of East Greenbush, are accessible for the\nlifetime of the customer relationship, and may be made available to the\nTown Board and to members of the public.\n\n5. Records of hot list matches, alerts, or notifications generated by the\nsystem, and records of any evidence exports, saved searches, or case\nattachments.\n\nREDACTION\n\nI am not requesting license plate numbers in this request. If searched\nplate numbers appear in the audit records, I accept their redaction. I do\nnot accept redaction of the searching user, agency, date and time, stated\nreason, case number, or search scope fields. Please accompany any redaction\nwith the specific statutory basis under Public Officers Law \u00a7 87(2).\n\nFORMAT AND CUSTODY\n\nPlease provide records electronically in native export format or as CSV,\nconsistent with Public Officers Law \u00a7 87(5). If any responsive records are\nmaintained by the vendor rather than on Town equipment, please note that\nFOIL reaches records within an agency's possession or control, and advise\nwhat the Town is able to retrieve through its own administrative access.\n\nIf any portion of this request is denied, please identify the specific\nsubsection relied upon and provide the name and address of the person or\nbody designated to hear appeals.\n\nPlease acknowledge receipt within five business days and provide a date\ncertain for production, as required by Public Officers Law \u00a7 89(3). If a\nfee is asserted, please provide an itemized estimate before proceeding.\n\nThank you for your time."
 },
 {
  "path": "FOIL and Emails/FOIL/FOIL Request B (2026-07-27) - Flock Detection Records, Full Retention Period/FOIL Request B (2026-07-27) - Flock Detection Records, Full Retention Period.eml",
  "date": "Mon, 27 Jul 2026 17:33:57 -0400",
  "iso": "2026-07-27T17:33:57-04:00",
  "from": "Eric <publiusnewyork@gmail.com>",
  "to": "epangburn@eastgreenbush.org",
  "cc": "",
  "subj": "FOIL Request B (2026-07-27) - Flock Detection Records, Full Retention Period",
  "body": "Ellen Pangburn\nTown Clerk / Records Access Officer\nTown of East Greenbush\n225 Columbia Turnpike\nRensselaer, NY 12144\n\nDear Ms. Pangburn,\n\nPursuant to the New York Freedom of Information Law, Public Officers Law\nArticle 6, I request the following records concerning the automated license\nplate reader (ALPR) system operated by or on behalf of the Town of East\nGreenbush.\n\nThis is one of three related requests I am submitting today, and is\nseparate from my Request A (audit log data) and Request C (policy and\ngovernance records) of the same date.\n\nRECORDS REQUESTED\n\nAll detection or capture records currently retained by the system, covering\nthe full retention period available at the time this request is processed.\nFor each detection, I request all associated data fields, including but not\nlimited to: license plate number; date and time of capture; camera\nidentifier and location, including GPS coordinates; direction of travel;\nand all vehicle characteristics derived by the system, including make,\nmodel, color, body type, and any identifying features such as roof racks,\nbumper stickers, or damage.\n\nI also request the associated images themselves where retained.\n\nSCOPE NOTE\n\nThis request differs in scope from Request A. In Request A I stated that I\nwould accept redaction of plate numbers appearing in audit records. That\naccommodation applies to Request A only and is not extended here. This\nrequest is for the detection records themselves, unredacted.\n\nIF DENIED\n\nIf this request is denied in whole or in part, I ask that the response\nstate:\n\n1. The specific subsection of Public Officers Law \u00a7 87(2) relied upon for\neach category of information withheld; and\n\n2. Whether the Town asserts \u00a7 87(2)(b), unwarranted invasion of personal\nprivacy, as a ground for withholding - and if so, whose privacy interest is\nasserted and what characteristics of these records give rise to it.\n\nI ask for a direct answer to point 2 because the Town's public position,\nstated at the July 15, 2026 Town Board meeting, is that this system\ncaptures only images of vehicles in public view. If the Town's position on\ndisclosure is that release of these records would constitute an unwarranted\ninvasion of personal privacy, I would like that stated in writing so that\nboth positions are before the Board in advance of the September 16 public\nhearing.\n\nTIMING\n\nThese records are deleted on a rolling basis, so the responsive set shrinks\neach day this request is pending. If the volume makes full production\nimpracticable, I am willing to discuss narrowing by date range or by camera\nlocation - but I ask that any such discussion not delay the statutory\nresponse deadlines.\n\nFORMAT AND CUSTODY\n\nPlease provide records electronically in native export format or CSV,\nconsistent with Public Officers Law \u00a7 87(5). If the records are held by the\nvendor rather than on Town equipment, please advise what the Town can\nretrieve through its administrative access, and identify the contractual\nprovision governing the Town's access rights.\n\nPlease acknowledge receipt within five business days and provide a date\ncertain for production, as required by Public Officers Law \u00a7 89(3). If a\nfee is asserted, please provide an itemized estimate before proceeding.\n\nThank you for your time."
 },
 {
  "path": "FOIL and Emails/FOIL/FOIL Request C (2026-07-27) - ALPR Policy, Sharing Agreements, and System Configuration/FOIL Request C (2026-07-27) - ALPR Policy, Sharing Agreements, and System Configuration.eml",
  "date": "Mon, 27 Jul 2026 17:36:33 -0400",
  "iso": "2026-07-27T17:36:33-04:00",
  "from": "Eric <publiusnewyork@gmail.com>",
  "to": "epangburn@eastgreenbush.org",
  "cc": "",
  "subj": "FOIL Request C (2026-07-27) - ALPR Policy, Sharing Agreements, and  System Configuration",
  "body": "Ellen Pangburn\nTown Clerk / Records Access Officer\nTown of East Greenbush\n225 Columbia Turnpike\nRensselaer, NY 12144\n\nDear Ms. Pangburn,\n\nPursuant to the New York Freedom of Information Law, Public Officers Law\nArticle 6, I request the following records concerning the governance,\nconfiguration, and oversight of the automated license plate reader (ALPR)\nsystem operated by or on behalf of the Town of East Greenbush.\n\nThis is one of three related requests I am submitting today, and is\nseparate from my Request A (audit log data) and Request B (detection\nrecords) of the same date. I have separated the written policy and\ngovernance records from the system log data because they are likely held by\ndifferent offices. If these records are maintained by the East Greenbush\nPolice Department rather than the Town Clerk's office, please forward this\nrequest to the appropriate records access officer and advise me of the\nreferral.\n\nThis request covers the period from first use of any such system to the\npresent. Please treat \"since inception\" as controlling rather than any\nspecific year.\n\nRECORDS REQUESTED\n\nPolicy and governance\n\n1. Any policy, general order, standard operating procedure, memorandum,\ndirective, or user agreement governing the use of the ALPR system,\nincluding who may run searches, what constitutes an acceptable search\nreason, and how compliance is verified. This includes the internal policy\ndescribed by the Chief of Police at the July 15, 2026 Town Board meeting.\n\n2. Records of the monthly audit reviews described at that meeting -\nincluding who conducted each review, the period covered, findings, and any\ncorrective action taken.\n\n3. Any records of misuse, policy violation, discipline, or corrective\naction arising from use of the ALPR system, redacted as required by law.\n\n4. Any training materials or acknowledgment forms provided to or signed by\nusers of the system.\n\nSharing and access\n\n5. All records identifying the agencies with which Town of East Greenbush\nALPR data is shared, and all records of the Town's requests to access or\nsearch other agencies' data. This includes the monthly sharing report\nreferenced by the Chief of Police at the July 15, 2026 meeting, for all\nmonths retained.\n\n6. Any written agreement, memorandum of understanding, or reciprocal\nsharing arrangement between the Town of East Greenbush and any other agency\ngoverning ALPR data access.\n\n7. Records showing whether any federal agency has had access to Town ALPR\ndata, and if so, which agencies and on what basis.\n\nConfiguration and its history\n\n8. The current retention period applicable to detection or capture records,\ntogether with a complete history of any changes to that setting since\ninception, including the date of each change and who authorized it.\n\n9. Records showing whether the system is currently configured to REQUIRE a\nsearch reason and a case number to be entered at the time a search is\nperformed, and the history of any changes to that setting. If either field\nis optional rather than system-enforced, please so state.\n\n10. Records showing whether the Town has enabled the search filters\ndescribed at the July 15 meeting that prevent searches related to\nimmigration or reproductive care, and the date on which any such filter was\nenabled.\n\n11. Records showing whether the Town participates in the vendor's data use\nfor product improvement under Section 4.1 of the terms and conditions, and\nany election, opt-in, or opt-out the Town has made.\n\nContract\n\n12. The current agreement with Flock Safety and all amendments, including\nthe amendment reducing the deployment from nine cameras to five, and any\nrenewal, quotation, or purchase order under consideration.\n\nIf any portion of this request is denied, please identify the specific\nsubsection of Public Officers Law \u00a7 87(2) relied upon and provide the name\nand address of the person or body designated to hear appeals.\n\nPlease provide records electronically where available, consistent with\nPublic Officers Law \u00a7 87(5). Please acknowledge receipt within five\nbusiness days and provide a date certain for production, as required by\nPublic Officers Law \u00a7 89(3). If a fee is asserted, please provide an\nitemized estimate before proceeding.\n\nThank you for your time."
 },
 {
  "path": "FOIL and Emails/FOIL/Status Request - Four Pending FOIL Requests (Jul 20 and Jul 27)/Status Request - Four Pending FOIL Requests (Jul 20 and Jul 27).eml",
  "date": "Wed, 5 Aug 2026 10:05:35 -0400",
  "iso": "2026-08-05T10:05:35-04:00",
  "from": "Eric <publiusnewyork@gmail.com>",
  "to": "epangburn@eastgreenbush.org",
  "cc": "",
  "subj": "Status Request - Four Pending FOIL Requests (Jul 20 and Jul 27)",
  "body": "Ms. Pangburn,\n\nI'm writing for a status update on the FOIL requests I have pending with\nthe Town, and to make sure none of them have been lost in transit rather\nthan simply queued.\n\nAcknowledged:\n  Jul 16 - ALPR devices installed or in trial within town limits\n(acknowledged Jul 17)\n  Jul 16 - Flock contract, cost, procurement, grant funding, ALPR policy\n(acknowledged Jul 17)\n\nNot yet acknowledged:\n  Jul 20 - Communications with Flock representatives; vendor-provided\ngoods, services, hospitality, or trial equipment\n  Jul 27 - Request A: Flock network and organization audit logs, since\ninception\n  Jul 27 - Request B: Flock detection records, full retention period\n  Jul 27 - Request C: ALPR policy, sharing agreements, and system\nconfiguration\n\nI received an out-of-office auto-reply to my July 20 request indicating you\nwere away July 20\u201324, directing inquiries in the interim to Johnna, Deputy\nClerk, or Ellen Schwab, Clerk, and stating you would reply the week of July\n27. Your last substantive response to me was July 17.\n\nI'd rather assume these four are sitting in a queue, or never arrived, than\ntreat them as denied. If any of them did not reach your office, please tell\nme and I will resend the same day. If they did arrive and are simply\npending, an acknowledgment with a date certain is all I need for now.\n\nI would ask for the following:\n\n1. Written acknowledgment of each of the four outstanding requests, with a\ndate certain for production, by Wednesday, August 12, 2026.\n\n2. Prioritization of Request B (detection records). Those records are\ndeleted on a rolling basis, so the responsive set shrinks every day the\nrequest is pending. If the Town intends to deny Request B, an early denial\nis more useful to me than a late one.\n\n3. The name and address of the person or body designated to determine FOIL\nappeals for the Town, which I requested in each of the July 27 filings.\n\nOn overlap: my July 27 requests do overlap in part with the July 16\nrequests. They are not duplicates - A, B, and C seek the system's own audit\nlogs, the detection records themselves, and specific configuration\nsettings, none of which were sought earlier. Where a single document is\nresponsive to more than one request, one production is fine. I would ask\nthat the overlap not result in any request being closed as duplicative.\n\nI would also note that Supervisor Conway stated at the July 15 Town Board\nmeeting that no fee would apply to records requests concerning the Flock\nsystem. I took that as an invitation to seek these records through the\nproper channel, which is what I have done, and I have tried to keep each\nrequest specific enough to be answerable.\n\nI'm glad to discuss narrowing scope or sequencing if that would help move\nthings along.\n\nFinally, only for record: Public Officers Law \u00a7 89(3) provides five\nbusiness days for acknowledgment along with a date certain for production.\nAs of today, August 5, that window has lapsed for all four of the requests\nlisted above -  on July 27 for the July 20 request, and on August 3 for\nRequests A, B, and C. I mention it not to press the point but because I\nwould rather raise it now, while this can still be handled as a scheduling\nmatter, than have it treated later as something else.\n\nThank you for your time."
 },
 {
  "path": "FOIL and Emails/FOIL/Status Request - Four Pending FOIL Requests (Jul 20 and Jul 27)/Eric w_Publius - RE_ Status Request - Four Pending FOIL Requests (Jul 20 and Jul 27).eml",
  "date": "Wed, 5 Aug 2026 14:32:43 +0000",
  "iso": "2026-08-05T14:32:43+00:00",
  "from": "Ellen Pangburn <epangburn@eastgreenbush.org>",
  "to": "Eric <publiusnewyork@gmail.com>",
  "cc": "Johnna Eurich <jeurich@eastgreenbush.org>",
  "subj": "Eric w/Publius - RE: Status Request - Four Pending FOIL Requests (Jul  20 and Jul 27)",
  "body": "Good morning, Kara,\n\nPlease see below PD FOIL.\n\nThank you.\n\nEllen\n\nFrom: Eric <publiusnewyork@gmail.com>\nSent: Wednesday, August 5, 2026 10:06 AM\nTo: Ellen Pangburn <epangburn@eastgreenbush.org>\nSubject: Status Request - Four Pending FOIL Requests (Jul 20 and Jul 27)\n\nMs. Pangburn,\n\nI'm writing for a status update on the FOIL requests I have pending with the Town, and to make sure none of them have been lost in transit rather than simply queued.\n\nAcknowledged:\n  Jul 16 - ALPR devices installed or in trial within town limits (acknowledged Jul 17)\n  Jul 16 - Flock contract, cost, procurement, grant funding, ALPR policy (acknowledged Jul 17)\n\nNot yet acknowledged:\n  Jul 20 - Communications with Flock representatives; vendor-provided goods, services, hospitality, or trial equipment\n  Jul 27 - Request A: Flock network and organization audit logs, since inception\n  Jul 27 - Request B: Flock detection records, full retention period\n  Jul 27 - Request C: ALPR policy, sharing agreements, and system configuration\n\nI received an out-of-office auto-reply to my July 20 request indicating you were away July 20\u201324, directing inquiries in the interim to Johnna, Deputy Clerk, or Ellen Schwab, Clerk, and stating you would reply the week of July 27. Your last substantive response to me was July 17.\n\nI'd rather assume these four are sitting in a queue, or never arrived, than treat them as denied. If any of them did not reach your office, please tell me and I will resend the same day. If they did arrive and are simply pending, an acknowledgment with a date certain is all I need for now.\n\nI would ask for the following:\n\n1. Written acknowledgment of each of the four outstanding requests, with a date certain for production, by Wednesday, August 12, 2026.\n\n2. Prioritization of Request B (detection records). Those records are deleted on a rolling basis, so the responsive set shrinks every day the request is pending. If the Town intends to deny Request B, an early denial is more useful to me than a late one.\n\n3. The name and address of the person or body designated to determine FOIL appeals for the Town, which I requested in each of the July 27 filings.\n\nOn overlap: my July 27 requests do overlap in part with the July 16 requests. They are not duplicates - A, B, and C seek the system's own audit logs, the detection records themselves, and specific configuration settings, none of which were sought earlier. Where a single document is responsive to more than one request, one production is fine. I would ask that the overlap not result in any request being closed as duplicative.\n\nI would also note that Supervisor Conway stated at the July 15 Town Board meeting that no fee would apply to records requests concerning the Flock system. I took that as an invitation to seek these records through the proper channel, which is what I have done, and I have tried to keep each request specific enough to be answerable.\n\nI'm glad to discuss narrowing scope or sequencing if that would help move things along.\n\nFinally, only for record: Public Officers Law \u00a7 89(3) provides five business days for acknowledgment along with a date certain for production. As of today, August 5, that window has lapsed for all four of the requests listed above -  on July 27 for the July 20 request, and on August 3 for Requests A, B, and C. I mention it not to press the point but because I would rather raise it now, while this can still be handled as a scheduling matter, than have it treated later as something else.\n\nThank you for your time."
 },
 {
  "path": "FOIL and Emails/FOIL/Status Request - Four Pending FOIL Requests (Jul 20 and Jul 27)/Follow-up_ FOIL request status and date certain.eml",
  "date": "Fri, 7 Aug 2026 15:07:28 -0400",
  "iso": "2026-08-07T15:07:28-04:00",
  "from": "Eric <publiusnewyork@gmail.com>",
  "to": "Ellen Pangburn <epangburn@eastgreenbush.org>",
  "cc": "Johnna Eurich <jeurich@eastgreenbush.org>",
  "subj": "Re: Follow-up: FOIL request status and date certain",
  "body": "Ellen,\n\nThank you, this is helpful, and I appreciate you confirming all six and\nfollowing up with the PD next week. I also appreciate the appeals\ninformation. Could you send me the name of the current Town Attorney, so I\nhave it on file?\n\nOne point on timing I wanted to raise, and I'm raising it now rather than\nlater so it's easy to sort out.\n\nPublic Officers Law Section 89(3)(a) provides that where an agency\ndetermines a request will take longer than twenty business days, it is to\nprovide a written statement of the reason together with a date certain when\nthe request will be granted or denied. As I read it, the date is owed once\nthe agency knows the twenty days won't be met, rather than after the twenty\ndays have run. Your August 5 message already reported that the PD expects\nall six to take longer than twenty business days, so I think that point has\nbeen reached.\n\nThe reason I'm asking rather than waiting is the calendar. The two July 16\nrequests were acknowledged July 17, which puts twenty business days around\nAugust 14. The July 20 request and the three July 27 requests were\nacknowledged August 5, which puts twenty business days around September 2.\nIf a tentative date is only issued after those dates pass, the earliest\ntentative date for four of the six would come in early September, with the\nrecords themselves following after that. The Town Board session on the\nFlock cameras is September 16.\n\nI'm not asking anyone to work faster than they can. Any date I can plan\naround is workable. If some or all of this can be targeted for before\nSeptember 16, that would be the most useful outcome, but a date is the part\nI actually need.\n\nOn that note, I'd like to repeat one offer, because I think it would help\nboth of us. These six are not equally large. The Flock contract and the\nDepartment's written ALPR policy, if one exists, are each a single document\nand could likely be produced quickly. The audit logs and detection records\nare the genuinely lengthy ones. I'm glad to take any request in parts, on a\nrolling basis, rather than waiting for a complete response. If the PD can\nsend the short documents now, the remaining work gets smaller and I stop\nbeing a moving target for them.\n\nThank you again for staying on top of this.\n\nEric\n\nOn Fri, Aug 7, 2026, 2:31\u202fPM Ellen Pangburn <epangburn@eastgreenbush.org>\nwrote:\n\n> Hi Eric,\n>\n>\n>\n> Confirmed \u2013 all (6) FOILS below have been submitted to our Police\n> Department. You should have received acknowledgement emails for each from\n> me.\n>\n>\n>\n> If you do not receive your reply within 20 business days, a tentative date\n> will be issued.\n>\n>\n>\n> I will follow up with our PD next week on status.\n>\n>\n>\n> On FOIL Request form - ADDRESS APPEALS TO: EAST GREENBUSH TOWN ATTORNEY, 225\n> COLUMBIA TURNPIKE, RENSSELAER, NY 12144\n> <https://www.google.com/maps/search/225+COLUMBIA+TURNPIKE,+RENSSELAER,+NY+12144?entry=gmail&source=g>\n>\n>\n>\n> Thank you.\n>\n>\n>\n> Ellen\n>\n>\n>\n> *From:* Eric <publiusnewyork@gmail.com>\n> *Sent:* Friday, August 7, 2026 1:31 PM\n> *To:* Ellen Pangburn <epangburn@eastgreenbush.org>\n> *Subject:* Follow-up: FOIL request status and date certain\n>\n>\n>\n> Ms. Pangburn,\n>\n>\n>\n> Thank you for your response of August 5 and for confirming in writing that\n> no fee applies to these requests. I appreciate the quick reply.\n>\n>\n>\n> Two things I'd ask for clarification on.\n>\n>\n>\n> First, I want to make sure we have the same list. Could you confirm the\n> status of each of the following individually?\n>\n>\n>\n> - July 16 - ALPR devices installed or in trial within Town limits\n>\n> - July 16 - Flock contract, cost, procurement, grant funding, and ALPR\n> policy\n>\n> - July 20 - communications with Flock representatives, and vendor-provided\n> goods, hospitality, or trial equipment\n>\n> - July 27 (Request A) - audit logs\n>\n> - July 27 (Request B) - detection records\n>\n> - July 27 (Request C) - policy and configuration records\n>\n>\n>\n> For each, I'd like to know whether it has been acknowledged, whether it is\n> with the Police Department, and its current status.\n>\n>\n>\n> Second, your response noted that these will take longer than twenty\n> business days. Public Officers Law Section 89(3)(a) provides that where a\n> request cannot be granted within twenty business days, the agency shall\n> provide a written statement of the reason for the delay and a date certain,\n> within a reasonable period, when the request will be granted or denied. I\n> have the reason but not the date. Could you provide a date certain for each\n> request?\n>\n>\n>\n> I raise the timing because the Town Board has a session scheduled for\n> September 16 at which the Flock cameras are on the agenda. Records produced\n> after that date would not be available to residents or to the Board while\n> the matter is under consideration. I'm not asking the Department to work\n> faster than it can. I'm asking for a date, so that I know what to expect\n> and can plan accordingly.\n>\n>\n>\n> If any request would be quicker to fill in parts, I'm glad to receive\n> records on a rolling basis rather than waiting for a complete response.\n> Several of these are short documents and could likely be produced well\n> ahead of the larger ones.\n>\n>\n>\n> I also asked for the name and address of the person or body designated to\n> hear FOIL appeals for the Town. I'd appreciate that whenever it's\n> convenient.\n>\n>\n>\n> Thank you again for your help with this.\n>\n>\n>\n> Eric\n>"
 },
 {
  "path": "FOIL and Emails/FOIL/FOIL REQUEST E - Town Board Records of Prior ALPR Presentations and Approvals/FOIL REQUEST E - Town Board Records of Prior ALPR Presentations and Approvals.eml",
  "date": "Tue, 18 Aug 2026 15:42:47 -0400",
  "iso": "2026-08-18T15:42:47-04:00",
  "from": "Eric <publiusnewyork@gmail.com>",
  "to": "Ellen Pangburn <epangburn@eastgreenbush.org>",
  "cc": "",
  "subj": "FOIL REQUEST E - Town Board Records of Prior ALPR Presentations and Approvals",
  "body": "Ms. Pangburn,\n\nPursuant to the New York Freedom of Information Law, Public Officers Law\nArticle 6 (Sections 84-90), I request copies of the following records. This\nrequest is separate from and additional to my requests of July 16, July 20,\nand July 27, 2026.\n\n*Time period:* January 1, 2019 through July 15, 2026.\n\nI do not know the exact date of the Town Board's original action on this\nmatter, so I have stated the request by subject matter and by date range\nrather than by a specific meeting date. Please treat any responsive record\nwithin the stated range as within scope.\n\n*Records requested:*\n\n   1. Agendas, minutes, and audio or video recordings of any Town Board\n   meeting, workshop, work session, or special meeting at which automated\n   license plate readers, Flock Safety, or any ALPR vendor was presented,\n   demonstrated, discussed, or voted upon.\n   2. Any record identifying attendance by a representative, agent, or\n   employee of Flock Safety or any other ALPR vendor at a Town Board meeting,\n   workshop, or work session - including sign-in sheets, agendas listing the\n   presenter, and correspondence scheduling the appearance.\n   3. The text of any resolution, motion, or authorization by which the\n   Town Board approved, amended, or declined to approve the acquisition,\n   installation, lease, or use of ALPR cameras, together with the recorded\n   vote on each.\n   4. Any record reflecting an amendment to the number of ALPR cameras\n   authorized, including any change from a larger to a smaller number of\n   devices.\n   5. Minutes of any executive session at which ALPR technology or Flock\n   Safety was discussed, and the motion stating the statutory basis on which\n   that executive session was entered, per Public Officers Law Section 105.\n   6. Any staff memorandum, department request, budget request, grant\n   application, or written recommendation submitted to the Town Board\n   concerning ALPR acquisition, renewal, or expansion.\n   7. Any record reflecting Town Board review, approval, or authorization\n   of a renewal, extension, or auto-renewal of an ALPR agreement after the\n   original approval.\n   8. Any procurement record generated under the Town's procurement policy\n   adopted pursuant to General Municipal Law Section 104-b in connection with\n   the acquisition of ALPR equipment or services, including any determination\n   that competitive bidding was not required.\n\n*Format:* Please provide records in electronic format (PDF, native file\nformat, or a link to audio/video files) by email to the address above, per\nPublic Officers Law Section 87(5). Where a recording exists, I request the\nrecording itself and not solely the written minutes.\n\n*Fees:* Supervisor Conway stated on the record at the July 15, 2026 Town\nBoard meeting that no fee would apply to Flock-related FOIL requests, and\nyour written response of August 5, 2026 confirmed that no fee applies to my\nFlock-related requests. I understand no fee applies here. If the Town takes\na different position, please notify me before incurring any cost.\n\n*Partial denials:* If any record or portion of a record is withheld, please\nidentify the record withheld and cite the specific statutory exemption\nrelied upon, per Public Officers Law Section 89(4)(a).\n\nI look forward to your acknowledgment within five business days as required\nby Public Officers Law Section 89(3)(a).\n\nThank you for your assistance."
 },
 {
  "path": "FOIL and Emails/FOIL/FOIL REQUEST F - Hotlist Topic Selections and System Policy Settings/FOIL REQUEST F - Hotlist Topic Selections and System Policy Settings.eml",
  "date": "Thu, 20 Aug 2026 10:25:19 -0400",
  "iso": "2026-08-20T10:25:19-04:00",
  "from": "Eric <publiusnewyork@gmail.com>",
  "to": "Ellen Pangburn <epangburn@eastgreenbush.org>",
  "cc": "",
  "subj": "FOIL REQUEST F - Hotlist Topic Selections and System Policy Settings",
  "body": "Ms. Pangburn,\n\nPursuant to the New York Freedom of Information Law, Public Officers Law\nArticle 6 (Sections 84-90), I request copies of the following records. This\nrequest is deliberately narrow. Each item is a single screen within the\nFlock Safety administrative interface, and other agencies have produced\nthese records as screenshots. I am not asking for any search of files or\ncorrespondence.\n\n*Item 1 (primary).* The list of National Crime Information Center (NCIC)\nhotlist topics currently selected by the East Greenbush Police Department\nwithin the Flock Safety system, showing which topics are enabled and which\nare disabled.This selection appears in the Flock administrative interface\nas a list of NCIC categories with individual toggles or checkboxes. I\nrequest the record in whatever form the Department can most easily produce\nit, including a screenshot of that screen, a printout, an export, or a\nwritten list of the selected topics.\n\n*Item 2 (secondary, and severable from Item 1).* The Department's Flock\nSafety \"Policies\" settings page or its equivalent, showing the Department's\ncurrent configuration for audit assistance, federal agency sharing, and any\nrestricted or prohibited search categories.\n\n*If Item 2 would require additional time, I ask that Item 1 be produced\nseparately and without waiting for it.* Item 1 is a single screen and\nshould not be deferred behind any other request.\n\n*Note on comparable productions.* The Elmira Police Department in New York\nhas produced its NCIC hotlist topic selections in response to a similar\nrequest. That production is publicly available here:\nhttps://www.documentcloud.org/documents/28311839-elmira-police-department-ny-ncic-topics/\n\nAn illustration of the screen itself appears in a June 25, 2026 article by\nthe Electronic Frontier Foundation:\nhttps://www.eff.org/files/2026/06/24/image1.png\n\nI include these only to identify the record clearly and to indicate the\nlevel of effort involved, not to suggest any particular response. If they\nare not helpful, please disregard them; the description above should be\nsufficient on its own. I would prefer to use as little of the Department's\ntime as possible on this request, and I leave the format entirely to its\ndiscretion.\n\n*Time period:* The current configuration as of the date this request is\nfilled. If the Department maintains any log or history of changes to these\nsettings, I request that as well, though I understand it may not exist.\n\n*Format:* Please provide records in electronic format by email to the\naddress above, per Public Officers Law Section 87(5). An image file or PDF\nis entirely acceptable.\n\n*Fees:* Your written response of August 5, 2026 confirmed that no fee\napplies to my Flock-related requests. I understand no fee applies here. If\nthe Town takes a different position, please notify me before incurring any\ncost.\n\n*Partial denials:* If any record or portion of a record is withheld, please\nidentify the record withheld and cite the specific statutory exemption\nrelied upon, per Public Officers Law Section 89(4)(a).\n\n*Date certain:* Please acknowledge receipt within five business days and\nprovide a date certain for production, as required by Public Officers Law\nSection 89(3)(a).\n\nThank you for your assistance."
 },
 {
  "path": "FOIL and Emails/Email/Flock records ahead of the September 16 session/Flock records ahead of the September 16 session.eml",
  "date": "Thu, 20 Aug 2026 11:38:22 -0400",
  "iso": "2026-08-20T11:38:22-04:00",
  "from": "Eric <publiusnewyork@gmail.com>",
  "to": "Jack Conway <jconway@eastgreenbush.org>",
  "cc": "",
  "subj": "Re: Flock records ahead of the September 16 session",
  "body": "Supervisor Conway,\n\nThank you. These are exactly the two documents I was asking for, and having\nthem in hand well before September 16 is what matters most.\n\nI appreciate you taking the time to get them, and doing it quickly.\n\nEric\n\nOn Thu, Aug 20, 2026 at 10:24\u202fAM Jack Conway <jconway@eastgreenbush.org>\nwrote:\n\n> Eric,\n>\n>\n>\n> We\u2019re not going to make a decision on September 16th.  That will be an\n> opportunity for people to be heard, including residents, FLOCK reps and our\n> police department.  I\u2019m looking for a full and fair discussion.  It won\u2019t\n> be a discussion of FLOCK cameras in general (I honestly don\u2019t care what\n> happens in Troy) but a discussion about FLOCK cameras in East Greenbush.\n> Because I have voted \u2018No\u2019 on these cameras (and will most likely do so\n> again), I\u2019m going to have to bend over backwards to make sure that people\n> in favor of them are heard.  When I said that FOILs would be free of charge\n> I thought I was talking to East Greenbush but we have been inundated with\n> requests from all over.  I\u2019m not going to be research central for the Troy\n> discussion.  Anyone from Troy who wants public information about FLOCK\n> cameras should FOIL the City.\n>\n>\n>\n> I have attached the FLOCK service agreement and our Department policy.  I\n> hope this helps.\n>\n>\n>\n> All the best, Jack\n>\n>\n>\n> *From:* Eric <publiusnewyork@gmail.com>\n> *Sent:* Tuesday, August 18, 2026 4:14 PM\n> *To:* Jack Conway <jconway@eastgreenbush.org>\n> *Subject:* Flock records ahead of the September 16 session\n>\n>\n>\n> Supervisor Conway,\n>\n> At the July 15 meeting about the Flock cameras you invited FOIL, and\n> waived the fees. I took you up on it that week. I'm writing because a month\n> later I have received nothing, and I don't believe the records will be in\n> front of the Board on September 16 unless something changes.\n>\n> Here is where it stands. I filed two requests on July 16 and they were\n> acknowledged the next day. The twenty business day mark on those was August\n> 14. It passed last Friday with no records and no production date. Four more\n> requests, filed July 20 and July 27, are also pending with no date.\n>\n> I want to be clear that this is not a complaint about Ellen Pangburn. She\n> has been responsive throughout, acknowledged the first two requests within\n> a day, confirmed the fee waiver in writing, and told me on August 7 she\n> would follow up with the Police Department. The Department has a backlog of\n> other requests, and two of mine are genuinely large. I am not asking anyone\n> to work faster than they can.\n>\n> What I am asking is that the Board not decide this without the record in\n> front of it.\n>\n> I have two specific requests.\n>\n> First, could you send me the flock contract? The Flock agreement/contract\n> is a Town contract. As Supervisor you can ask the Chief for a copy directly\n> rather than through a records request. It is one document. If the Board is\n> going to decide on September 16 whether to continue or expand this program,\n> every member should have read the actual terms before that night, and so\n> should the public. The same goes for the Department's written ALPR policy,\n> if one exists. Neither of those is a large production, and neither should\n> have to wait behind the audit logs.\n>\n> Second, the timeline. At the July meeting you said the Board should ask\n> its questions, and that where it can't get answers, the answer is no. I'd\n> take that seriously in both directions. If the contract, the written\n> policy, search records, and Public FOIL requests are still outstanding on\n> September 16, I'd ask that the Board not treat that night as the point of\n> decision, and instead hold the discussion over until the records are in\n> hand. A program that has run for four years can wait another month for its\n> own paperwork.\n>\n> I'd also note the Chief committed at the July meeting to producing a\n> summary of what the cameras have accomplished by September 16. I'd be\n> interested to know whether that is on track, and whether it will be\n> circulated in advance rather than presented for the first time that evening.\n>\n> Thank you for setting the September date and for being straightforward in\n> July. I appreciated it, and I'm raising this now rather than after, so\n> there is time to sort it out.\n>\n> Eric\n> publiusnewyork@gmail.com\n>"
 },
 {
  "path": "FOIL and Emails/Email/Advisory opinion request - date certain under POL \u00a7 89(3)(a)/Advisory opinion request - date certain under POL \u00a7 89(3)(a).eml",
  "date": "Thu, 20 Aug 2026 12:11:23 +0000",
  "iso": "2026-08-20T12:11:23+00:00",
  "from": "\"dos.sm.Coog.InetCoog\" <dosCOOG@dos.ny.gov>",
  "to": "Eric <publiusnewyork@gmail.com>",
  "cc": "",
  "subj": "=?iso-8859-1?Q?RE:_Advisory_opinion_request_-_date_certain_under_POL_=A7_?=  =?iso-8859-1?Q?89(3)(a)?=",
  "body": "Good morning,\n\nAgencies are required to provide a written response to a FOIL request within five business days either: (i) granting access; (ii) denying access and providing the basis for the denial; (iii) stating the agency does not possess the record sought (or that the record cannot be located after a diligent search); or (iv) acknowledging receipt of the request and providing \"a statement of the approximate date, which shall be reasonable under the circumstances of the request, when such request will be granted or denied.\" \ufffd 89(3)(a). The five-business day response must accomplish one of the above. If the automatic response you received did not do so, it would, in our opinion, not be consistent with the requirements of FOIL.\n\nOnce a request is acknowledged, agencies are generally permitted twenty business days to search for responsive records, grant or deny access and prepare the requested records. When an agency believes that requiring more than twenty business days to make a determination is reasonable based on the circumstances of the request, it must notify the requestor of a \"date certain\" as well as the reasons why the request cannot be fulfilled within twenty business days. 21 NYCRR 1401.5(c)(4).\n\nWith respect to constructive denials, the FOIL Regulations provide\n\n A failure to comply with the time limitations described herein shall constitute a denial of a request that may be appealed. Such failure shall include situations in which an agency:\n\n(1) fails to grant access to the records sought, deny access in writing or acknowledge the receipt of a request within five business days of the receipt of a request;\n(2) acknowledges the receipt of a request within five business days but fails to furnish an approximate date when it will grant or deny a request in whole or in part;\n(3) furnishes an acknowledgment of the receipt of a request within five business days with an approximate date for granting or denying access in whole or in part that is unreasonable under the circumstances of the request;\n(4) fails to respond to a request within a reasonable time after the approximate date given or within twenty business days after the date of its acknowledgment of the receipt of a request;\n(5) determines to grant a request in whole or in part within twenty business days of its acknowledgment of the receipt of a request, but fails to do so, unless the agency provides the reason for its inability to do so in writing and a date certain within which the request will be granted in whole or in part;\n(6) does not grant a request in whole or in part within twenty business days of its acknowledgment of the receipt of a request and fails to provide the reason in writing explaining its inability to do so and a date certain by which the request will be granted in whole or in part; or\n(7) responds to a request, stating that more than twenty business days is needed to grant or deny the request in whole or in part and provides a date certain within which it will do so, but such date is unreasonable under the circumstances of the request.\n\n21 NYCRR 1401.5(e).\n\nFailure to provide a date certain, failure to provide a reason that is consistent with the Regulations, or providing a response date that is otherwise unreasonable under the circumstances of the request, can be appealed as a constructive denial. If you believe that the timeframe constitutes a constructive denial, you may appeal to the agency's appeals officer. The appeals officer must issue a written determination within ten business days of receipt. Failure to do so constitutes a constructive denial of the appeal and the requestor may seek judicial review by initiating an Article 78 proceeding in state supreme court.\n\nWith respect to your third question, FOIL presumes that agencies will conduct a diligent search for responsive records in response to a FOIL request. That term is not defined but generally means that the agency must search for the records in all locations where it would expect to find responsive records given its indexing and filing system. Whether a particular search conforms to these requirements is a fact specific determination for the judiciary.\n\nSincerely,\n\nChristen Smith (she/her/hers)\nSenior Attorney\n\nNew York Department of State\nCommittee on Open Government\n99 Washington Ave., Albany, NY 12231\nw: (518) 474-2518\nCommittee on Open Government | Open Government<https://opengovernment.ny.gov/>\n\nFrom: Eric <publiusnewyork@gmail.com>\nSent: Wednesday, August 19, 2026 4:15 PM\nTo: dos.sm.Coog.InetCoog <dosCOOG@dos.ny.gov>\nSubject: Advisory opinion request - date certain under POL \ufffd 89(3)(a)\n\nYou don't often get email from publiusnewyork@gmail.com<mailto:publiusnewyork@gmail.com>. Learn why this is important<https://aka.ms/LearnAboutSenderIdentification>\nAttention: This email came from an external source. Do not open attachments or click on links from unknown senders or unexpected emails.\n\nTo the Committee on Open Government:\n\nI am requesting an advisory opinion on a single question, and would be grateful for an oral response by telephone in the interim if that is possible.\n\nQuestion: Where an agency has determined and stated in writing that a request will require more than twenty business days, and has provided a reason but no date certain, has it satisfied Public Officers Law \ufffd 89(3)(a)? And does that failure constitute a denial under \ufffd 89(4)(a), such that an administrative appeal may be filed without waiting for the twenty business days to elapse?\n\nFacts. I filed six FOIL requests with the Town of East Greenbush between July 16 and July 27, 2026, concerning the Town's automated license plate reader system. Two were acknowledged July 17. Four were acknowledged August 5. No record of any kind has been produced.\n\nOn August 5, 2026 the Town's Records Access Officer wrote: \"I have received an update from our Police Department that your (2) prior FOIL Requests from 7/16 will take additional time beyond the 20 business days due to the length of the requests. That will be the same for the 7/20 request as well as the (3) for 7/27.\"\n\nNo date certain accompanied that statement, and none has been provided since. On August 7 the Town advised that \"If you do not receive your reply within 20 business days, a tentative date will be issued.\"\n\nThe twenty business day period on the two earliest requests expired August 14, 2026, with no production and no date.\n\nSecondary questions, if the Committee is able to address them:\n\n  1.  Is a statement that a tentative date will issue only after twenty business days elapse consistent with \ufffd 89(3)(a)?\n  2.  Is an automatic out-of-office reply an acknowledgment for purposes of the five-business-day requirement?\n  3.  Where a records access officer routes all requests to a single department, has the agency conducted a reasonable search when responsive records would ordinarily be held by the Clerk, Comptroller, or Supervisor?\n\nI am aware the Committee does not adjudicate. I am seeking guidance, and a citation to any prior opinion on point would be helpful.\n\nThe Town has scheduled a public hearing on this subject for September 16, 2026, which is why the timing matters.\n\nThank you.\n\nEric\npubliusnewyork@gmail.com<mailto:publiusnewyork@gmail.com>"
 },
 {
  "path": "FOIL and Emails/FOIL/FOIL REQUEST D - Vendor Materials Provided to the Police Department/Eric-102 -- FOIL REQUEST D - Vendor Materials Provided to the Police Department.eml",
  "date": "Thu, 20 Aug 2026 18:31:54 +0000",
  "iso": "2026-08-20T18:31:54+00:00",
  "from": "Ellen Pangburn <epangburn@eastgreenbush.org>",
  "to": "Eric <publiusnewyork@gmail.com>",
  "cc": "",
  "subj": "RE: Eric-102 -- FOIL REQUEST D - Vendor Materials Provided to the  Police Department",
  "body": "Good afternoon,\n\nI acknowledge receipt of your FOIL Request. I will notify you within 20 business days of your reply or let you know the status and a date your reply would be available.\n\nThank you.\n\nKind regards,\n\nEllen\n\nEllen Pangburn, RMC\nEast Greenbush Town Clerk\nRegistrar of Vital Statistics\nFOIL Officer / Notary Public\nepangburn@eastgreenbush.org<mailto:epangburn@eastgreenbush.org>\nPhone:  518.477.7145 / Fax:  518.477.4508\n225 Columbia Tpk., Rensselaer, NY 12144\nTown Clerk\u2019s Office hours: 8:30-4:30\n[cid:image001.jpg@01DD30B0.A4F30430]\n\nFrom: Eric <publiusnewyork@gmail.com>\nSent: Tuesday, August 18, 2026 3:44 PM\nTo: Ellen Pangburn <epangburn@eastgreenbush.org>\nSubject: FOIL REQUEST D - Vendor Materials Provided to the Police Department\n\nMs. Pangburn,\n\nPursuant to the New York Freedom of Information Law, Public Officers Law Article 6 (Sections 84-90), I request copies of the following records. This request is separate from and additional to my requests of July 16, July 20, and July 27, 2026.\n\nTime period: January 1, 2019 through the date this request is filled.\n\nRecords requested - any and all records in the possession of the Town of East Greenbush, its Police Department, or any Town officer or employee, that were created by, provided by, or received from Flock Safety (Flock Group Inc.), any Flock reseller, distributor, or sales agent, or any other automated license plate reader (ALPR) vendor, including:\n\n  1.  Sales presentations, slide decks, PDFs, brochures, product literature, one-pagers, and any other marketing or informational materials.\n  2.  Written proposals, quotes, price sheets, order forms, statements of work, and scoping documents.\n  3.  Demonstration and pilot materials, including trial or demo agreements, loaner or evaluation equipment agreements, and any records describing a free trial, pilot, or demonstration period.\n  4.  Product documentation, user guides, administrator guides, training materials, release notes, and feature descriptions.\n  5.  Screenshots, screen recordings, video recordings, or webinar recordings provided to or viewed by Department personnel.\n  6.  Correspondence - email, letters, text messages, or other written communication - between any Town officer or employee and any representative of Flock Safety or an ALPR vendor, including all attachments.\n  7.  Any non-disclosure, confidentiality, or similar agreement executed with an ALPR vendor.\n  8.  Any written question-and-answer document, FAQ, talking points, or response-to-questions record supplied by an ALPR vendor to Town or Department personnel.\n\nI specifically request that this include records that were provided to the Police Department or the Chief of Police but were not presented to the Town Board, as well as records provided in advance of, during, or following any presentation to the Town Board.\n\nIf any responsive record exists only in the custody of the Police Department, please forward this request accordingly, as you have done previously.\n\nFormat: Please provide records in electronic format (PDF or native file format) by email to the address above, per Public Officers Law Section 87(5).\n\nFees: Supervisor Conway stated on the record at the July 15, 2026 Town Board meeting that no fee would apply to Flock-related FOIL requests, and your written response of August 5, 2026 confirmed that no fee applies to my Flock-related requests. I understand no fee applies here. If the Town takes a different position, please notify me before incurring any cost.\n\nPartial denials: If any record or portion of a record is withheld, please identify the record withheld and cite the specific statutory exemption relied upon, per Public Officers Law Section 89(4)(a).\n\nI look forward to your acknowledgment within five business days as required by Public Officers Law Section 89(3)(a).\n\nThank you for your assistance."
 },
 {
  "path": "FOIL and Emails/FOIL/FOIL REQUEST F - Hotlist Topic Selections and System Policy Settings/Item 1-Page 2 _ - FOIL REQUEST F - Hotlist Topic Selections and System Policy Settings.eml",
  "date": "Fri, 21 Aug 2026 17:06:12 -0400",
  "iso": "2026-08-21T17:06:12-04:00",
  "from": "Eric <publiusnewyork@gmail.com>",
  "to": "Ellen Pangburn <epangburn@eastgreenbush.org>",
  "cc": "",
  "subj": "Re: Item 1-Page 2 ? - FOIL REQUEST F - Hotlist Topic Selections and  System Policy Settings",
  "body": "Ms. Pangburn,\n\nThank you for the quick acknowledgment.\n\nThat image isn't a record of mine, and there's no page 2 that I have. It's\nan illustration published showing what this screen looks like at another\nagency, and I included it only so the screen would be easy to identify. The\n13 versus 9 discrepancy is in their published image, which appears to be\ncut off.\n\nPlease disregard it entirely. I'm not asking the Department to match that\nformat or that agency's page. Whatever East Greenbush's own screen looks\nlike, in whatever form is easiest to produce, is exactly what I'm asking\nfor. A screenshot would all be fine.\n\nThank you.\n\nEric\n\nOn Thu, Aug 20, 2026 at 12:23\u202fPM Ellen Pangburn <epangburn@eastgreenbush.org>\nwrote:\n\n> Good afternoon,\n>\n>\n>\n> I acknowledge receipt of your FOIL Request. I will notify you within 20\n> business days of your reply or let you know the status and a date your\n> reply would be available.\n>\n>\n>\n> Please confirm if Image 1 attachment has a page 2. I only have one page\n> and at top it notes 13 Enabled Topics. Below that, only 9 are listed. If\n> there is a page 2, please send.\n>\n>\n>\n> Thank you.\n>\n>\n>\n> Kind regards,\n>\n>\n>\n> Ellen\n>\n>\n>\n> Ellen Pangburn, RMC\n>\n> East Greenbush Town Clerk\n>\n> Registrar of Vital Statistics\n>\n> FOIL Officer / Notary Public\n>\n> epangburn@eastgreenbush.org\n>\n> Phone:  518.477.7145 / Fax:  518.477.4508\n>\n> 225 Columbia Tpk., Rensselaer, NY 12144\n>\n> *Town Clerk\u2019s Office hours: 8:30-4:30*\n>\n>\n>\n>\n>\n> *From:* Eric <publiusnewyork@gmail.com>\n> *Sent:* Thursday, August 20, 2026 10:25 AM\n> *To:* Ellen Pangburn <epangburn@eastgreenbush.org>\n> *Subject:* FOIL REQUEST F - Hotlist Topic Selections and System Policy\n> Settings\n>\n>\n>\n> Ms. Pangburn,\n>\n> Pursuant to the New York Freedom of Information Law, Public Officers Law\n> Article 6 (Sections 84-90), I request copies of the following records. This\n> request is deliberately narrow. Each item is a single screen within the\n> Flock Safety administrative interface, and other agencies have produced\n> these records as screenshots. I am not asking for any search of files or\n> correspondence.\n>\n> *Item 1 (primary).* The list of National Crime Information Center (NCIC)\n> hotlist topics currently selected by the East Greenbush Police Department\n> within the Flock Safety system, showing which topics are enabled and which\n> are disabled.This selection appears in the Flock administrative interface\n> as a list of NCIC categories with individual toggles or checkboxes. I\n> request the record in whatever form the Department can most easily produce\n> it, including a screenshot of that screen, a printout, an export, or a\n> written list of the selected topics.\n>\n> *Item 2 (secondary, and severable from Item 1).* The Department's Flock\n> Safety \"Policies\" settings page or its equivalent, showing the Department's\n> current configuration for audit assistance, federal agency sharing, and any\n> restricted or prohibited search categories.\n>\n> *If Item 2 would require additional time, I ask that Item 1 be produced\n> separately and without waiting for it.* Item 1 is a single screen and\n> should not be deferred behind any other request.\n>\n> *Note on comparable productions.* The Elmira Police Department in New\n> York has produced its NCIC hotlist topic selections in response to a\n> similar request. That production is publicly available here:\n> https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/28311839-elmira-police-department-ny-ncic-topics/\n>\n> An illustration of the screen itself appears in a June 25, 2026 article by\n> the Electronic Frontier Foundation:\n> https://www.eff.org/files/2026/06/24/image1.png\n>\n>\n>\n> I include these only to identify the record clearly and to indicate the\n> level of effort involved, not to suggest any particular response. If they\n> are not helpful, please disregard them; the description above should be\n> sufficient on its own. I would prefer to use as little of the Department's\n> time as possible on this request, and I leave the format entirely to its\n> discretion.\n>\n> *Time period:* The current configuration as of the date this request is\n> filled. If the Department maintains any log or history of changes to these\n> settings, I request that as well, though I understand it may not exist.\n>\n> *Format:* Please provide records in electronic format by email to the\n> address above, per Public Officers Law Section 87(5). An image file or PDF\n> is entirely acceptable.\n>\n> *Fees:* Your written response of August 5, 2026 confirmed that no fee\n> applies to my Flock-related requests. I understand no fee applies here. If\n> the Town takes a different position, please notify me before incurring any\n> cost.\n>\n> *Partial denials:* If any record or portion of a record is withheld,\n> please identify the record withheld and cite the specific statutory\n> exemption relied upon, per Public Officers Law Section 89(4)(a).\n>\n> *Date certain:* Please acknowledge receipt within five business days and\n> provide a date certain for production, as required by Public Officers Law\n> Section 89(3)(a).\n>\n> Thank you for your assistance.\n>\n>\n>"
 },
 {
  "path": "FOIL and Emails/Email/Town Procurement Policy/Town Procurement Policy.eml",
  "date": "Sun, 23 Aug 2026 19:50:48 -0400",
  "iso": "2026-08-23T19:50:48-04:00",
  "from": "Eric <publiusnewyork@gmail.com>",
  "to": "Ellen Pangburn <epangburn@eastgreenbush.org>",
  "cc": "",
  "subj": "Town Procurement Policy",
  "body": "Ms. Pangburn,\n\nChapter 5 of the Town Code says the current procurement policy (\nhttps://ecode360.com/38967766#38967766) is on file in your office.\n\nRather than file a records request for it, could you email me a copy at\nyour convenience?\n\nI'd also appreciate the resolution adopting it and any amendments if they\nare easily available, but the policy itself is what I'm after.\n\nThank you.\nEric"
 },
 {
  "path": "FOIL and Emails/FOIL/FOIL Replies - Eric w PubliusNY - 78 and 79 ALPR Cost-Funding/FOIL Replies - Eric w_PubliusNY - 78 and 79 ALPR_Cost-Funding.eml",
  "date": "Tue, 25 Aug 2026 08:00:00 -0400",
  "iso": "2026-08-25T08:00:00-04:00",
  "from": "Eric <publiusnewyork@gmail.com>",
  "to": "Ellen Pangburn <epangburn@eastgreenbush.org>",
  "cc": "",
  "subj": "Re: FOIL Replies - Eric w/PubliusNY - 78 and 79 ALPR/Cost-Funding",
  "body": "Ms. Pangburn,\n\nThank you for this, and please pass my thanks along to the Police\nDepartment. I received the 8/24 reply to my two July 16 requests, and I\nappreciate the Town waiving the fee. I know these two were larger than most\nof what comes across your desk, and I appreciate the work that went into\npulling 56 pages together.\n\nI have gone through the production against the numbered items in each\nrequest. A number of items appear to have no responsive records in what was\nproduced. The reply form is marked \"Requested Record/s Attached\" with\nnothing indicating a partial response, so before I rely on it I want to\ncheck how the Town intends it.\n\nIs the 8/24 production the Town's complete response to both requests, or is\nmore still coming?\n\nI also want to flag one thing for the record. On August 21 I filed an\nadministrative appeal covering these two requests along with four others,\nwhich I understand was forwarded to Mr. Gruenberg. The August 24 production\nsubstantially answers parts of both July 16 requests, and I would like the\nappeal record to reflect that. Could you please forward this message to Mr.\nGruenberg as well, so that what remains in dispute on those two requests is\nnarrowed to the items listed below rather than the requests as a whole. I\nwould still appreciate his email address if you are able to share it.\n\nIf the production is complete, then each of my original requests included\nthis line:\n\n\"If no records exist that are responsive to any numbered item above, I\nrequest, pursuant to Public Officers Law 89(3), a written certification\nthat the Town does not possess such records for that item.\"\n\nI am renewing that here. I have gone item by item below rather than sending\nyou back to the original requests, and I have left out the items I believe\nwere fully answered. For each one, either the record or a certification\nthat it does not exist works for me. I recognize a certification may need\nto come from whoever conducted the search, or from the Town Attorney, and I\nam fine with whatever routing makes sense.\n\n>From my request of July 16, 8:46 AM (contract, cost, procurement, grant\nfunding, ALPR policy):\n\n   - Item 1 - The agreements and amendments were produced. Two things were\n   not: the quote referenced in Resolution 148-2022 (\"a quote has been\n   provided by Flock Safety for Five Stationary License Plate Readers\"), and\n   any renewal documents. The invoice provided, INV-71462, is marked \"Renewal\n   - 2024: Year 2 of 24 Month Term, 2025-2026,\" which suggests a renewal\n   record exists somewhere.\n   - Item 2 - One invoice was produced, for 2025. I am asking for invoices,\n   vouchers, purchase orders, or proof of payment covering the other years,\n   and the budget line or appropriation records for account code 31204.01,\n   which Resolution 148-2022 names.\n   - Item 3 - Nothing responsive was produced regarding grant applications,\n   grant awards, or correspondence about potential grant funding, including\n   any grant work performed by Lexipol or another consultant.\n   - Item 4 - Nothing responsive was produced regarding the procurement\n   method, competitive bidding, a cooperative purchasing agreement, or an\n   exemption under General Municipal Law 103.\n   - Item 5 - A draft policy was produced. I am asking for any adopted ALPR\n   policy, and any earlier version in effect between 2021 and now.\n   - Item 6 - The production covers currently installed devices. I am also\n   asking for proposed or planned devices and locations, including anything\n   concerning Condor or other camera types.\n   - Item 8 - Resolution 148-2022 was produced. I am asking for Town Board\n   minutes relating to the approval or consideration of any Flock agreement,\n   and any resolution or authorization for the trial period that Resolution\n   148-2022 refers to, or for the agreement executed on 9/28/2021.\n\n>From my request of July 16, 8:14 AM (ALPR devices installed or in trial):\n\n   1. Item 1 - The camera list provides locations and current status. I am\n   also asking for installation date, owner, operator, and the agency or\n   entity whose database receives each device's data.\n   2. Item 3 - Nothing responsive was produced regarding permits, licenses,\n   right-of-way authorizations, pole attachment agreements, or approvals of\n   any kind.\n   3. Item 4 - Nothing responsive was produced regarding Department access\n   to or participation in any Flock Safety database or data-sharing network,\n   user accounts issued to Town personnel, or memoranda of understanding or\n   data-sharing agreements with other agencies. This subject also falls inside\n   one of my July 27 requests. I am not looking for the same records twice, so\n   if the Department would rather answer it there, just let me know and I will\n   drop it from this one.\n\nTwo questions I think can be answered from records already in hand:\n\n   - A. Policy 426 as produced is marked DRAFT on every page with a\n   publication date of 8/11/2026. Has it been adopted, and if so when, and\n   what policy or procedure governed ALPR use before it? The copy also appears\n   to end mid-section at 426.7, so it may be worth confirming the full\n   document came through.\n   - B. Under Section 6.1 of the Government Agency Customer Agreement, the\n   agreement renews automatically unless notice of non-renewal is given at\n   least thirty days before the end of the current term. What is the end date\n   of the current term, and the last date the Town could give that notice?\n\nI am asking about the September 16 meeting only so I can plan around it.\nAnything I present needs to be accurate. If some of these records will not\nbe available by then, I would rather describe the status of these requests\naccurately than guess at what is behind them, so a clear list of which\nitems would be all I need.\n\nThank you again.\n\nEric\npubliusnewyork@gmail.com"
 },
 {
  "path": "FOIL and Emails/FOIL/Administrative Appeal under FOIL - six requests filed July 16, July 20 and July 27, 2026/Administrative Appeal under FOIL - six requests filed July 16, July 20 and July 27, 2026(1).eml",
  "date": "Fri, 28 Aug 2026 14:33:10 +0000",
  "iso": "2026-08-28T14:33:10+00:00",
  "from": "Ellen Pangburn <epangburn@eastgreenbush.org>",
  "to": "Eric <publiusnewyork@gmail.com>",
  "cc": "",
  "subj": "RE: Administrative Appeal under FOIL - six requests filed July 16,  July 20 and July 27, 2026",
  "body": "Hi Eric,\n\nYou\u2019re welcome.\n\nYou may call David Gruenberg at 518.274.7252 regarding your appeal.\n\nBest,\n\nEllen\n\nFrom: Eric <publiusnewyork@gmail.com>\nSent: Thursday, August 27, 2026 2:50 PM\nTo: Ellen Pangburn <epangburn@eastgreenbush.org>\nSubject: Re: Administrative Appeal under FOIL - six requests filed July 16, July 20 and July 27, 2026\n\nMs. Pangburn,\nThank you again for confirming that the appeal was forwarded on August 24.\n\nIs there an email address where I can reach Mr. Gruenberg directly regarding this appeal, or should any further correspondence on it continue to go through your office?\n\nOn Thu, Aug 27, 2026, 1:42\u202fPM Ellen Pangburn <epangburn@eastgreenbush.org<mailto:epangburn@eastgreenbush.org>> wrote:\nGood afternoon, Eric,\n\nYou\u2019re welcome.\n\nYes, your FOIL Appeal was forwarded to David Gruenberg, attorney to the Town and also FOIL Appeals Officer, on Monday, August 24th.\n\nAs stated on FOIL Request form, any appeals are to be addressed to: East Greenbush Town Attorney, 225 Columbia Tpk., Rensselaer, NY 12144<https://www.google.com/maps/search/225+Columbia+Tpk.,+Rensselaer,+NY+12144?entry=gmail&source=g>. Or, since you forwarded appeal to me via email, email was forwarded to Mr. Gruenberg.\n\nBest,\n\nEllen\n\nFrom: Eric <publiusnewyork@gmail.com<mailto:publiusnewyork@gmail.com>>\nSent: Wednesday, August 26, 2026 11:00 AM\nTo: Ellen Pangburn <epangburn@eastgreenbush.org<mailto:epangburn@eastgreenbush.org>>\nSubject: Re: Administrative Appeal under FOIL - six requests filed July 16, July 20 and July 27, 2026\n\nMs. Pangburn,\n\nThank you again for your help with all of this. I know I have sent a lot your way over the past several weeks, and you have been consistently responsive.\n\nI am writing only to confirm one thing. On Friday, August 21 at 1:55 PM I sent you an administrative appeal, with a request that you forward it to Mr. Gruenberg as the Attorney to the Town. I believe he is the FOIL appeals officer, but that has only been confirmed to me by position rather than by name. Could you let me know whether it was forwarded, and on what date?\n\nI ask because I have not been able to find an email address or direct contact for Mr. Gruenberg anywhere on the Town's website. The Attorneys page lists his name and role but no contact information, and he does not appear in the staff directory. Since you are the Town's designated FOIL Officer, sending the appeal to you and asking you to forward it seemed like the correct path, and I want to make sure it reached him.\n\nIf there is a better way to reach him directly, or if the designated appeals officer is someone other than the Town Attorney, please let me know and I will send it there as well.\n\nMy understanding is that the ten business day period under Public Officers Law Section 89(4)(a) runs from the Town's receipt, which I take to be August 21. That would put a determination around September 4. I am not raising that as a complaint. I simply want to be sure the appeal is in the right hands and that nothing was lost in transit.\n\nThank you as always.\n\nEric\n\nOn Fri, Aug 21, 2026 at 1:55\u202fPM Eric <publiusnewyork@gmail.com<mailto:publiusnewyork@gmail.com>> wrote:\n\nMs. Pangburn,\n\nThank you for the prompt acknowledgments this week of FOIL requests D and E in two business days, and F the same day. I genuinely appreciate it.\n\nI could not locate an email address for Mr. Gruenberg. From the Town's website I understand he is the Attorney to the Town, and you advised on August 7 that appeals are addressed to the Town Attorney, so I believe he is the person designated to determine FOIL appeals.\n\nAttached is an administrative appeal from the constructive denial of six of my earlier requests, those filed July 16, July 20 and July 27. Could you please forward it to  Mr. Gruenberg , and let me know if the designated appeals officer is someone else?\n\nIf you can send me his email address, or let me know the best way to reach him directly, I would appreciate it.\n\nI have also attached a written response I received from the Committee on Open Government, which the appeal references.\n\nI want to say plainly that this appeal is not directed at your office. You have been responsive throughout and confirmed the fee waiver in writing, and I have said so in the appeal itself. My concern is that no date has been issued and the Board's hearing is September 16.\n\nThank you for forwarding this.\n\nEric"
 },
 {
  "path": "FOIL and Emails/Email/Town Procurement Policy/Town Procurement Policy _ Resolution.eml",
  "date": "Fri, 28 Aug 2026 14:38:57 +0000",
  "iso": "2026-08-28T14:38:57+00:00",
  "from": "Ellen Pangburn <epangburn@eastgreenbush.org>",
  "to": "Eric <publiusnewyork@gmail.com>",
  "cc": "",
  "subj": "RE: Town Procurement Policy / Resolution",
  "body": "Hi Eric,\n\nPlease see below link for policy on our website. Resolution attached as requested.\n\nhttps://www.eastgreenbush.org/departments/department_of_finance/purchasing/purchasing_policy.php\n\nBest,\n\nEllen\n\nFrom: Eric <publiusnewyork@gmail.com>\nSent: Sunday, August 23, 2026 7:51 PM\nTo: Ellen Pangburn <epangburn@eastgreenbush.org>\nSubject: Town Procurement Policy\n\nMs. Pangburn,\n\nChapter 5 of the Town Code says the current procurement policy (https://ecode360.com/38967766#38967766<https://ecode360.com/38967766#38967766>) is on file in your office.\n\nRather than file a records request for it, could you email me a copy at your convenience?\n\nI'd also appreciate the resolution adopting it and any amendments if they are easily available, but the policy itself is what I'm after.\n\nThank you.\nEric"
 },
 {
  "path": "FOIL and Emails/FOIL/Status Updates/Status Updates - Eric w_publiusny.eml",
  "date": "Tue, 1 Sep 2026 20:13:23 +0000",
  "iso": "2026-09-01T20:13:23+00:00",
  "from": "Ellen Pangburn <epangburn@eastgreenbush.org>",
  "to": "Eric <publiusnewyork@gmail.com>",
  "cc": "Johnna Eurich <jeurich@eastgreenbush.org>",
  "subj": "RE: Status Updates - Eric w/publiusny",
  "body": "Eric,\n\nPlease see updates below.\n\nI wanted to provide an update regarding all Flock FOILs acknowledged by you on August 5th, 2026. The first request filed on July 20th, 2026, requesting \"communications with Flock safety representatives and related vendor provided goods, services, or hospitality\", this will be fulfilled, I do understand that 20 business days expires September 2nd, this will take longer than that to track down as these communications happened prior to me being in this position. I estimate that I will be able to gather this information by September 11th, 2026.\n\nThe 3 requests filed on July 27th, 2026, will take a longer period of time to complete. Organizational, network and detection record audits are fulfilled by one Sergeant in this department and are only able to be run in 30-day periods. The Sergeant being able to run this data is dependent on call volume as we are a small agency and you never know when an emergency could occur that we have to respond to. I approximate that an organizational audit can be produced within 2 months of this email. I am still working on getting an approximate date from the Sergeant in charge of Flock for the rest of the audits and I will forward that to you once I have received it.\n\nBest,\n\nEllen\n\nFrom: Eric <publiusnewyork@gmail.com>\nSent: Monday, August 31, 2026 12:32 PM\nTo: Ellen Pangburn <epangburn@eastgreenbush.org>\nSubject: Status Updates\n\nEllen,\n\nI am seeking status updates only in this email. (no new records and nothing to do with the appeal.)\n\nOn August 5 you let me know the PD expects these to run past twenty business days. Could I get an approximate date for each of the seven still open?\n\n- Jul 20 - Flock communications and vendor-provided items\n- Jul 27 A - audit logs\n- Jul 27 B - detection records\n- Jul 27 C - policy and system configuration\n- D - vendor materials provided to the PD\n- E - prior Flock presentation and procurement records\n- F - hotlist topic selections and system policy settings\n\nTwo things that might make it easier. I am happy to take these in pieces as they are ready, nothing needs to be held. And if a small starting point helps, the piece of C I most want is the Flock sharing configuration and its change history, which would be satisfied by screenshots of the admin settings pages.\n\nNone of this is aimed at your office. I just have a September 16 Board date and no date to work against.\n\nThanks,\n\nEric"
 },
 {
  "path": "FOIL and Emails/Email/Two procedural questions on the Flock contract, ahead of Sept 9/JConway/Two procedural questions on the Flock contract, ahead of Sept 9.eml",
  "date": "Fri, 4 Sep 2026 08:00:00 -0400",
  "iso": "2026-09-04T08:00:00-04:00",
  "from": "Eric <publiusnewyork@gmail.com>",
  "to": "Jack Conway <JConway@eastgreenbush.org>",
  "cc": "",
  "subj": "Two procedural questions on the Flock contract, ahead of Sept 9",
  "body": "Supervisor Conway\n\nI have been following the Town's Flock camera contract and filing records\nrequests since July. I am not writing to ask you to take a position on the\ncameras. I am writing about two procedural questions worth the Board's\nattention regardless of where anyone stands on the technology.\n\nIn October 2020 this Board adopted the State Archives retention schedule,\nLGS-1, by Resolution 214-2020. It passed unanimously and directed that Town\nrecords be disposed of only after meeting the minimum retention set out in\nthat schedule. LGS-1 sets one year as the minimum for license plate reader\ndata.\n\nAt the July 15 meeting the Town's Flock retention was stated as 30 days,\nand on August 13 Flock announced it is moving its recommended default from\n30 days to seven. I do not know which setting the system is currently on.\n\nI do not think anyone at the Town did this deliberately. I think a vendor\ndefault was never checked against a resolution the Board passed the year\nbefore the cameras arrived.\n\nThe two things I would ask the Board to consider:\n\n   1. Direct the Town Clerk, as records management officer, to determine\n   whether the Town's Flock retention setting conforms to LGS-1, and report\n   back.\n   2. Require a Board resolution before any renewal or extension of the\n   Flock agreement, consistent with the Town's own purchasing policy for\n   service contracts of $10,000 and over.\n\nNeither costs anything. Neither cancels anything. The first is a question\nthe Clerk can answer. The second is what the Town's purchasing policy\nalready requires.\n\nI plan to raise this briefly at the Pre-Board meeting on September 9. If\nyou have questions before then I am glad to answer them, and glad to send\nthe underlying documents.\n\nThank you for your time,\n\nEric publiusnewyork@gmail.com"
 },
 {
  "path": "FOIL and Emails/Email/Two procedural questions on the Flock contract, ahead of Sept 9/matters/Two procedural questions on the Flock contract, ahead of Sept 9.eml",
  "date": "Fri, 4 Sep 2026 08:08:00 -0400",
  "iso": "2026-09-04T08:08:00-04:00",
  "from": "Eric <publiusnewyork@gmail.com>",
  "to": "matters@eastgreenbush.org",
  "cc": "",
  "subj": "Two procedural questions on the Flock contract, ahead of Sept 9",
  "body": "Councilor Matters,\n\nI have been following the Town's Flock camera contract and filing records\nrequests since July. I am not writing to ask you to take a position on the\ncameras. I am writing about two procedural questions worth the Board's\nattention regardless of where anyone stands on the technology.\n\nI am writing to you in particular because you seconded Resolution 214-2020,\nwhich is the resolution this comes back to.\n\nThat resolution adopted the State Archives retention schedule, LGS-1, and\ndirected that Town records be disposed of only after meeting the minimum\nretention set out in it. It passed unanimously on October 21, 2020. LGS-1\nsets one year as the minimum for license plate reader data.\n\nAt the July 15 meeting the Town's Flock retention was stated as 30 days,\nand on August 13 Flock announced it is moving its recommended default from\n30 days to seven. I do not know which setting the system is currently on.\n\nI do not think anyone at the Town did this deliberately. I think a vendor\ndefault was never checked against a resolution the Board passed the year\nbefore the cameras arrived.\n\nThe two things I would ask the Board to consider:\n\n   1. Direct the Town Clerk, as records management officer, to determine\n   whether the Town's Flock retention setting conforms to LGS-1, and report\n   back.\n   2. Require a Board resolution before any renewal or extension of the\n   Flock agreement, consistent with the Town's own purchasing policy for\n   service contracts of $10,000 and over.\n\nNeither costs anything. Neither cancels anything. The first is a question\nthe Clerk can answer. The second is what the Town's purchasing policy\nalready requires.\n\nI plan to raise this briefly at the Pre-Board meeting on September 9. If\nyou have questions before then I am glad to answer them, and glad to send\nthe underlying documents.\n\nThank you for your time,\n\nEric publiusnewyork@gmail.com"
 },
 {
  "path": "FOIL and Emails/Email/Two procedural questions on the Flock contract, ahead of Sept 9/McHugh/Two procedural questions on the Flock contract, ahead of Sept 9.eml",
  "date": "Fri, 4 Sep 2026 09:05:00 -0400",
  "iso": "2026-09-04T09:05:00-04:00",
  "from": "Eric <publiusnewyork@gmail.com>",
  "to": "McHugh@eastgreenbush.org",
  "cc": "",
  "subj": "Two procedural questions on the Flock contract, ahead of Sept 9",
  "body": "Councilor McHugh\n\nI have been following the Town's Flock camera contract and filing records\nrequests since July. I am not writing to ask you to take a position on the\ncameras. I am writing about two procedural questions worth the Board's\nattention regardless of where anyone stands on the technology.\n\nIn October 2020 this Board adopted the State Archives retention schedule,\nLGS-1, by Resolution 214-2020. It passed unanimously and directed that Town\nrecords be disposed of only after meeting the minimum retention set out in\nthat schedule. LGS-1 sets one year as the minimum for license plate reader\ndata.\n\nAt the July 15 meeting the Town's Flock retention was stated as 30 days,\nand on August 13 Flock announced it is moving its recommended default from\n30 days to seven. I do not know which setting the system is currently on.\n\nI do not think anyone at the Town did this deliberately. I think a vendor\ndefault was never checked against a resolution the Board passed the year\nbefore the cameras arrived.\n\nThe two things I would ask the Board to consider:\n\n   1. Direct the Town Clerk, as records management officer, to determine\n   whether the Town's Flock retention setting conforms to LGS-1, and report\n   back.\n   2. Require a Board resolution before any renewal or extension of the\n   Flock agreement, consistent with the Town's own purchasing policy for\n   service contracts of $10,000 and over.\n\nNeither costs anything. Neither cancels anything. The first is a question\nthe Clerk can answer. The second is what the Town's purchasing policy\nalready requires.\n\nI plan to raise this briefly at the Pre-Board meeting on September 9. If\nyou have questions before then I am glad to answer them, and glad to send\nthe underlying documents.\n\nThank you for your time,\n\nEric publiusnewyork@gmail.com"
 },
 {
  "path": "FOIL and Emails/Email/Two procedural questions on the Flock contract, ahead of Sept 9/lkoenig/Two procedural questions on the Flock contract, ahead of Sept 9.eml",
  "date": "Fri, 4 Sep 2026 10:01:00 -0400",
  "iso": "2026-09-04T10:01:00-04:00",
  "from": "Eric <publiusnewyork@gmail.com>",
  "to": "lkoenig@eastgreenbush.org",
  "cc": "",
  "subj": "Two procedural questions on the Flock contract, ahead of Sept 9",
  "body": "Councilor Koenig,\n\nI have been following the Town's Flock camera contract and filing records\nrequests since July. I am not writing to ask you to take a position on the\ncameras. I am writing about two procedural questions worth the Board's\nattention regardless of where anyone stands on the technology.\n\nIn October 2020 this Board adopted the State Archives retention schedule,\nLGS-1, by Resolution 214-2020. It passed unanimously and directed that Town\nrecords be disposed of only after meeting the minimum retention set out in\nthat schedule. LGS-1 sets one year as the minimum for license plate reader\ndata.\n\nAt the July 15 meeting the Town's Flock retention was stated as 30 days,\nand on August 13 Flock announced it is moving its recommended default from\n30 days to seven. I do not know which setting the system is currently on.\n\nI do not think anyone at the Town did this deliberately. I think a vendor\ndefault was never checked against a resolution the Board passed the year\nbefore the cameras arrived.\n\nThe two things I would ask the Board to consider:\n\n   1. Direct the Town Clerk, as records management officer, to determine\n   whether the Town's Flock retention setting conforms to LGS-1, and report\n   back.\n   2. Require a Board resolution before any renewal or extension of the\n   Flock agreement, consistent with the Town's own purchasing policy for\n   service contracts of $10,000 and over.\n\nNeither costs anything. Neither cancels anything. The first is a question\nthe Clerk can answer. The second is what the Town's purchasing policy\nalready requires.\n\nI plan to raise this briefly at the Pre-Board meeting on September 9. If\nyou have questions before then I am glad to answer them, and glad to send\nthe underlying documents.\n\nThank you for your time,\n\nEric publiusnewyork@gmail.com"
 },
 {
  "path": "FOIL and Emails/Email/Three questions - retention setting and status/Three questions - retention setting and status.eml",
  "date": "Fri, 4 Sep 2026 11:01:00 -0400",
  "iso": "2026-09-04T11:01:00-04:00",
  "from": "Eric <publiusnewyork@gmail.com>",
  "to": "Ellen Pangburn <epangburn@eastgreenbush.org>",
  "cc": "",
  "subj": "Three questions - retention setting and status",
  "body": "Ellen,\n\nThank you for the September 1 update. The dates are genuinely helpful and I\nappreciate you chasing them down.\n\nThree questions below. To be clear at the outset, none of these narrows or\nwithdraws any request. Everything I have filed stands in full, and I am\nstill seeking all of the records described in each.\n\n1. Do detection records from July 2026 still exist in the Flock system, or\nhas the retention period already passed over them? I am asking because the\nTown's Flock retention was stated as 30 days at the July 15 meeting. If the\nrecords still exist I want them. If they no longer exist, I am requesting a\nwritten statement to that effect under Public Officers Law 89(3),\nidentifying the date range no longer available and the date the records\nwere disposed of.\n\n2. What is the Town's current Flock data retention setting? It was stated\nas 30 days on July 15, and Flock announced on August 13 that it is changing\nits recommended default from 30 days to seven. I am trying to understand\nwhat the Town is set to today and whether that is changing.\n\n3. Could I get a status on the three requests acknowledged the week of\nAugust 17? Your September 1 update covered the four acknowledged on August\n5, which makes sense, but those three were not included.\n\nOn the first question in particular, I am asking because the Town Board\nadopted the State Archives schedule LGS-1 by Resolution 214-2020, and I am\ntrying to understand how the Flock retention period relates to it. That may\nbe a question for your office rather than the Police Department.\n\nThanks again,\n\nEric"
 },
 {
  "path": "FOIL and Emails/Email/For Attorney to the Town - Flock Safety agreement question/For Attorney to the Town - Flock Safety agreement question.eml",
  "date": "Fri, 4 Sep 2026 13:03:00 -0400",
  "iso": "2026-09-04T13:03:00-04:00",
  "from": "Eric <publiusnewyork@gmail.com>",
  "to": "Ellen Pangburn <epangburn@eastgreenbush.org>",
  "cc": "Eric <publiusnewyork@gmail.com>",
  "subj": "For Attorney to the Town - Flock Safety agreement question",
  "body": "Ellen,\n\nCould you please forward the below to Mr. Gruenberg. No response is needed\nfrom your office.\n\nThank you,\nEric\n\n---\n\nDear Mr. Gruenberg,\n\nSeparate from the administrative appeal I filed on August 21, I am writing\nwith questions about the Flock Safety agreement that are not records\nrequests and that I do not think the Clerk's office can answer. I am\nraising them with you because they concern what the contract permits and\nwhat the Town is able to verify.\n\n*Records retention*\n\n1. On October 21, 2020 the Town Board adopted the State Archives schedule\nLGS-1, resolving that Town records be disposed of only after meeting the\nminimum retention set out in it. LGS-1 Item 1241(b) provides a one-year\nretention for license plate reader data. Has the Town assessed whether the\nFlock retention configuration conforms to that resolution?\n\n2. Does the Town take the position that ALPR data hosted on Flock's systems\nconstitutes a Town record for retention and disposition purposes? Public\nOfficers Law 86(4) reaches information kept, held, filed, produced or\nreproduced by, with or for an agency.\n\n*Preservation*\n\n3. On August 13, 2026 Flock announced an Evidence Mode feature permitting\nagencies to preserve specific records past the retention window. Did the\nTown have any mechanism available in July 2026 to preserve ALPR records\nupon receipt of a records request, and was any such mechanism used in\nresponse to my requests of July 20 and July 27?\n\n4. Has the Town assessed whether it is able to comply with a records\nrequest for detection data given the current retention configuration and\nthe statutory response period?\n\n*Audit and vendor access*\n\n5. Does the agreement give the Town a contractual right to a complete audit\nrecord of system activity, including activity by Flock personnel or\ncontractors? Has the Town ever requested one?\n\n6. Can the Town independently verify that the audit records available to it\nthrough the Flock console are complete?\n\n*Contract execution*\n\n7. The amendment executed on behalf of the Town on December 16, 2024 was\nsigned by the Chief of Police. The Town's Purchasing Policies and\nProcedures Manual provides that the Town Supervisor has signing authority\nand that resolutions are required to designate anyone else. Was that\namendment executed under any written designation of signing authority?\n\nI am raising these ahead of the September 9 Pre-Board meeting because\nseveral bear on decisions the Board may face regarding renewal. I would be\nglad to receive answers in whatever form is convenient, and I recognize\nsome may take time.\n\nThank you,\n\nEric\npubliusnewyork@gmail.com"
 },
 {
  "path": "FOIL and Emails/Email/Two procedural questions on the Flock contract, ahead of Sept 9/hkennedy/Two procedural questions on the Flock contract, ahead of Sept 9.eml",
  "date": "Wed, 9 Sep 2026 14:18:04 -0400",
  "iso": "2026-09-09T14:18:04-04:00",
  "from": "Eric <publiusnewyork@gmail.com>",
  "to": "Hollie Kennedy <hkennedy@eastgreenbush.org>",
  "cc": "",
  "subj": "Re: Two procedural questions on the Flock contract, ahead of Sept 9",
  "body": "Councilor Kennedy,\n\nThank you for the direct answer. I'm ill and won't make tonight's\npre-board, but I'll be at the hearing on the 16th and will send written\ncomments to Ms. Pangburn.\n\nOn the second item, that settles it. If the Board requires a resolution\nbefore any extension or renewal, I have nothing further to raise.\n\nOn the first, your note that the retention period may be reduced is why I'm\nwriting tonight rather than waiting.\n\n   - I'm not asking the Board to keep this data longer. I'd rather the Town\n   kept less of it. I'm asking that the number be set deliberately, with the\n   retention schedule in front of you.\n   - Resolution 214-2020 adopted LGS-1 unanimously and directs that Town\n   records be disposed of only after meeting the minimum retention in that\n   schedule. LGS-1 lists license plate reader data at a one-year minimum, Item\n   1241(b). The Town's setting was stated as 30 days on July 15. A shorter\n   period moves further from that minimum, not closer. I suspect the schedule\n   item simply hasn't come up. LGS-1 covers hundreds of record types and this\n   one is easy to miss.\n\nSo one ask: before the retention changes, have the Clerk confirm what the\nschedule requires. If it applies and the Board still wants a shorter\nperiod, the State Archives has a process for seeking one.\n\nOne point I'd add. A vendor's default setting isn't something the Town is\nsubject to.* If Microsoft announced it would delete Town email after 30\ndays, the answer wouldn't be that Town email stopped being a Town record.*\n\nThank you again for engaging with this.\n\nEric\npubliusnewyork@gmail.com\n\nOn Wed, Sep 9, 2026 at 1:06\u202fPM Hollie Kennedy <hkennedy@eastgreenbush.org>\nwrote:\n\n> Eric, thank you for reaching out.\n>\n> The Town Board believes the best way to begin this flock camera process is\n> with a Public Hearing. The hearing will begin with a short presentation by\n> FLOCK representatives, followed by presentations from the East Greenbush\n> Police Department and Rensselaer County District Attorney, Mary Pat\n> Donnelly. Following these presentations, it will then be opened for public\n> comment. Written comments may be submitted to the Town Board by email to\n> epangburn@eastgreenbush.org, or by mail to the Town Board, Town of East\n> Greenbush, 225 Columbia Turnpike, Rensselaer, New York 12144\n> <https://www.google.com/maps/search/225+Columbia+Turnpike,+Rensselaer,+New+York+12144?entry=gmail&source=g>\n>\n> Regarding your requests, we already will require a board resolution before\n> any extension or renewal is made to the Flock agreement.\n> The retention schedule is under discussion at this time with consideration\n> being given to reducing it.\n>\n> The Town Board is interested in a comprehensive review of the program that\n> is based on how the residents feel about the program and how EGPD uses the\n> readers to assist in their efforts. The Town Board of the Town of East\n> Greenbush has scheduled a Public Hearing to hear comments on the FLOCK\n> License Plate Readers for September 16, 2026, at 6:00 p.m. at East\n> Greenbush Town Hall, 225 Columbia Turnpike, Rensselaer, NY 12144\n> <https://www.google.com/maps/search/225+Columbia+Turnpike,+Rensselaer,+NY+12144?entry=gmail&source=g>\n> .\n>\n> See you tonight at the pre-board meeting,.\n>\n> Hollie Kennedy\n> Councilor\n> ------------------------------\n> *From:* Eric <publiusnewyork@gmail.com>\n> *Sent:* Friday, September 4, 2026 8:00 AM\n> *To:* Hollie Kennedy <hkennedy@eastgreenbush.org>\n> *Subject:* Two procedural questions on the Flock contract, ahead of Sept 9\n>\n> Councilor Kennedy,\n>\n> I have been following the Town's Flock camera contract and filing records\n> requests since July. I am not writing to ask you to take a position on the\n> cameras. I am writing about two procedural questions worth the Board's\n> attention regardless of where anyone stands on the technology.\n>\n> I am writing to you in particular because you moved Resolution 214-2020,\n> which is the resolution this comes back to.\n>\n>\n> That resolution adopted the State Archives retention schedule, LGS-1, and\n> directed that Town records be disposed of only after meeting the minimum\n> retention set out in it. It passed unanimously on October 21, 2020. LGS-1\n> sets one year as the minimum for license plate reader data.\n>\n> At the July 15 meeting the Town's Flock retention was stated as 30 days,\n> and on August 13 Flock announced it is moving its recommended default from\n> 30 days to seven. I do not know which setting the system is currently on.\n>\n> I do not think anyone at the Town did this deliberately. I think a vendor\n> default was never checked against a resolution the Board passed the year\n> before the cameras arrived.\n>\n> The two things I would ask the Board to consider:\n>\n>    1. Direct the Town Clerk, as records management officer, to determine\n>    whether the Town's Flock retention setting conforms to LGS-1, and report\n>    back.\n>    2. Require a Board resolution before any renewal or extension of the\n>    Flock agreement, consistent with the Town's own purchasing policy for\n>    service contracts of $10,000 and over.\n>\n> Neither costs anything. Neither cancels anything. The first is a question\n> the Clerk can answer. The second is what the Town's purchasing policy\n> already requires.\n>\n> I plan to raise this briefly at the Pre-Board meeting on September 9. If\n> you have questions before then I am glad to answer them, and glad to send\n> the underlying documents.\n>\n> Thank you for your time,\n>\n> Eric publiusnewyork@gmail.com\n>"
 },
 {
  "path": "FOIL and Emails/FOIL/FOIL Request G - Purchasing and Procurement Records, Flock Safety/Reply - Rec'd - FOIL Request G - Purchasing and Procurement Records, Flock Safety.eml",
  "date": "Tue, 15 Sep 2026 20:04:13 +0000",
  "iso": "2026-09-15T20:04:13+00:00",
  "from": "Ellen Pangburn <epangburn@eastgreenbush.org>",
  "to": "Eric <publiusnewyork@gmail.com>",
  "cc": "Johnna Eurich <jeurich@eastgreenbush.org>",
  "subj": "RE: Reply - Rec'd - FOIL Request G - Purchasing and Procurement  Records, Flock Safety",
  "body": "Hi Eric,\n\nPlease see below text in blue as well as documents attached.\n\nI will follow up with further information from our Purchasing Department.\n\nBest,\n\nEllen\n\nFrom: Ellen Pangburn\nSent: Tuesday, September 1, 2026 4:29 PM\nTo: 'Eric' <publiusnewyork@gmail.com>\nCc: Johnna Eurich <jeurich@eastgreenbush.org>\nSubject: RE: Rec'd - FOIL Request G - Purchasing and Procurement Records, Flock Safety\n\nGood afternoon, Eric,\n\nI acknowledge receipt of your FOIL Request and have forwarded it to our Purchasing/Finance Department, as well as my office. I will let you know when I receive a reply within 20 business days or let you know the status.\n\nKind regards,\n\nEllen\n\nEllen Pangburn, RMC\nEast Greenbush Town Clerk\nRegistrar of Vital Statistics\nFOIL Officer / Notary Public\nepangburn@eastgreenbush.org<mailto:epangburn@eastgreenbush.org>\nPhone:  518.477.7145 / Fax:  518.477.4508\n225 Columbia Tpk., Rensselaer, NY 12144\nTown Clerk\u2019s Office hours: 8:30-4:30\n[cid:image001.jpg@01DD4526.799BF280]\n\nFrom: Eric <publiusnewyork@gmail.com<mailto:publiusnewyork@gmail.com>>\nSent: Monday, August 31, 2026 12:24 PM\nTo: Ellen Pangburn <epangburn@eastgreenbush.org<mailto:epangburn@eastgreenbush.org>>\nSubject: FOIL Request G - Purchasing and Procurement Records, Flock Safety\n\nEllen,\n\nThank you again for the link to the purchasing policy and for the resolution. This is a new request under the Freedom of Information Law, Public Officers Law Article 6.\n\nHaving reviewed the Purchasing Policies and Procedures Manual adopted by Resolution 132-2023, I am requesting the following records. Each relates to the Town's procurement of Flock Safety automated license plate reader cameras and services.\n\n1. The Purchasing Policy and Procedures in effect during calendar years 2021 and 2022, meaning the policy that Resolution 132-2023 amended and replaced.\nI have asked for this policy \u2013 will send separately. Also sending Resolution 132-2023 and May Minutes attached. Livestream link in Minutes.\n\n2. Records of the annual review and Town Board approval of the purchasing policy required by General Municipal Law 104-b, for each year from 2019 through the present.\n\n3. Any sole source or single source determination for Flock Safety, including the written findings of the Town Board setting forth the material and substantial reasons for that status, the alternatives considered, and the basis for determining the cost was reasonable; the Sole Source Justification Form; and any letter on Flock Safety letterhead supporting that determination.\n\n4. Any Purchase Justification Form or other documentation supporting the use of another government's contract, state contract, OGS contract, or GSA contract as the basis for the Flock Safety procurement.\n\n5. Any resolution, written designation, or other record authorizing a person other than the Town Supervisor to sign contracts, order forms, or amendments with Flock Safety. This request specifically includes any authorization applicable to the amendment executed on behalf of the Town on December 16, 2024.\n\n6. All purchase requisitions, purchase orders, and vouchers relating to any payment to Flock Safety from January 1, 2021 to the present.\nSee attached documents.\n\n7. All quotes obtained in connection with the Flock Safety procurement, and if fewer than the required number of quotes were obtained, the documentation stating the reasons why.\n\n8. All Town Board resolutions or Town Supervisor approvals authorizing the renewal, extension, or continuation of the Flock Safety agreement for each contract year from May 17, 2023 to the present.\nSee attached documents.\n\nPlease provide these records in electronic format by email to this address, as permitted by Public Officers Law 87(5). If any record is available on the Town website, a link is sufficient.\n\nIf any portion of this request is denied, please identify the specific statutory exemption relied upon and provide the name and address of the person or body to whom an administrative appeal should be directed.\n\nIf a record identified above does not exist, please state that in writing rather than omitting the item.\n\nThank you,\n\nEric"
 },
 {
  "path": "FOIL and Emails/FOIL/FOIL Request- Complete/FOIL Request- Complete.eml",
  "date": "Thu, 24 Sep 2026 17:11:34 +0000",
  "iso": "2026-09-24T17:11:34+00:00",
  "from": "Johnna Eurich <jeurich@eastgreenbush.org>",
  "to": "\"publiusnewyork@gmail.com\" <publiusnewyork@gmail.com>",
  "cc": "Ellen Pangburn <epangburn@eastgreenbush.org>",
  "subj": "FOIL Request- Complete",
  "body": "Good afternoon Eric,\nPlease see attached for information regarding your FOIL request.\nThis FOIL is complete and there are no monies owed at this time.\n\nBest,\nJohnna\n\n[cid:image001.jpg@01DD4C26.369A1A00]\n\nJohnna Eurich\nEast Greenbush Deputy Town Clerk\nDeputy Registrar of Vital Statistics\nNotary Public\njeurich@eastgreenbush.org<mailto:jeurich@eastgreenbush.org>\nPhone: 518-477-7145\nFax: 518-477-4508"
 },
 {
  "path": "FOIL and Emails/Email/Request to preserve Flock audit and query logs ahead of November 18/Request to preserve Flock audit and query logs ahead of November 18.eml",
  "date": "Sun, 15 Nov 2026 15:19:36 -0500",
  "iso": "2026-11-15T15:19:36-05:00",
  "from": "Eric <publiusnewyork@gmail.com>",
  "to": "Ellen Pangburn <epangburn@eastgreenbush.org>",
  "cc": "",
  "subj": "Request to preserve Flock audit and query logs ahead of November 18",
  "body": "Ellen,\n\nOne request, and it is not a FOIL request.\n\nThe Board takes up the Flock agreement on Wednesday. Section 6.4 of the\n2021 agreement provides that on termination Flock collects the units and\ndeletes all Agency Data, which includes the audit and query logs. My\nrequest of July 27 for those logs is still open.\n\nCould the Town preserve the following before any termination notice takes\neffect, by exporting and retaining copies under Town control:\n\n- the organization audit log\n- the network audit log\n- query logs\n- any detection data currently within the thirty-day retention window\n- camera configuration and hotlist settings\n- the data-sharing lists\n- the user account list\n\nOn October 21, 2020 the Board adopted the State Archives schedule LGS-1 by\nResolution 214-2020. Item 1241(b) sets a one-year minimum for license plate\nreader data and Item 1221a sets six years for license plate reader query\nlogs.\n\nOne thing worth checking now rather than later. Section 1.12 of Flock's\ncurrent online terms defines reports and analyses generated through the\nservice as Flock Property, with no right granted to export or retain\ncopies, and Section 4.1 limits access to the web interface to the retention\nperiod. It may be that the Town cannot export its own audit logs. If that\nis so, it would be better to know before Wednesday than after.\n\nIf it helps, I am glad to narrow this to whichever records are easiest to\nexport first.\n\nThank you,\nEric\npubliusnewyork@gmail.com"
 },
 {
  "path": "FOIL and Emails/Email/Written submission for the November 18, 2026 meeting - Flock agreement, status of attorney questions/Written submission for the November 18, 2026 meeting - Flock agreement, status of attorney questions.eml",
  "date": "Mon, 16 Nov 2026 09:38:38 -0500",
  "iso": "2026-11-16T09:38:38-05:00",
  "from": "Eric <publiusnewyork@gmail.com>",
  "to": "Ellen Pangburn <epangburn@eastgreenbush.org>",
  "cc": "Jack Conway <JConway@eastgreenbush.org>, matters@eastgreenbush.org,\n\tHollie Kennedy <hkennedy@eastgreenbush.org>, McHugh@eastgreenbush.org,\n\tlkoenig@eastgreenbush.org",
  "subj": "Re: Written submission for the November 18, 2026 meeting - Flock  agreement, status of attorney questions",
  "body": "Ellen,\n\nMy message yesterday attached the wrong file. Apologies for the confusion.\nThe two-page submission I described, on the status of the attorney\nquestions, is attached now.\n\nWhat went out instead was a letter intended for Mr. Gruenberg, on the\nagreement's dates and which version of the terms governs. I have attached\nthe final version of that as well, and would ask that it be forwarded to\nhim. No response is needed from your office on it.\n\nThe three requests in yesterday's message apply to both documents.\n\nThank you,\nEric\npubliusnewyork@gmail.com\n\nOn Sun, Nov 15, 2026 at 2:19\u202fPM Eric <publiusnewyork@gmail.com> wrote:\n\n> Ellen,\n>\n> Attached is a two-page written submission for the November 18, 2026 Town\n> Board meeting, together with the September 4, 2026 letter it refers to.\n>\n> Could you please:\n>\n> 1. Enter it into the record for that meeting,\n> 2. Include it with the materials distributed to the Town Board, and\n> 3. Retain it as correspondence under the Town's records schedule.\n>\n> I have copied the Board directly as well, so nothing depends on the timing\n> of the packet.\n>\n> If you could confirm in one line that it has been entered into the record,\n> I would appreciate it. That is the only response I need.\n>\n> Thank you for your help throughout this.\n>\n> Eric\n> publiusnewyork@gmail.com\n>"
 }
]